Skip to content

Docket Number C-2023-3041126

Case Summary
Docket Number C-2023-3041126 Status Active
Applicant PLANET ENERGY (PENNSYLVANIA) CORP D/B/A RITERATE ENERGY D/B/A VALUE PLUS ENERGY Utility Code 1113162
Complainant PUC BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION AND ENFORCEMENT Utility Name PLANET ENERGY (PENNSYLVANIA) CORP
Respondent PLANET ENERGY (PENNSYLVANIA) CORP D/B/A RITERATE ENERGY D/B/A VALUE PLUS ENERGY Utility Type Electric
Responsible Bureau ALJ eFiling Confirmation Number 2477393
Date Filed 06/01/2023 Date Posted 06/06/2023
Case Description BIE vs Planet Energy (Pennsylvania) Corp d/b/a RiteRate Energy d/b/a Value Plus Energy
Daily Actions
Action Date Description Date Posted
1/15/2025 Document Published on Web - Document 'Comments - BIE' is made public 1/15/2025
1/15/2025 Document Attached to Case - Comments - BIE - BIE filed Comments. 1/15/2025
1/2/2025 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Errata - Rewrite Opinion and Order - 3041126-ALJ - 11-7-24 PM - BIE v Planet Energy' is eServed 1/2/2025
1/2/2025 Document Published on Web - Document 'Rewrite Opinion and Order - 3041126-ALJ - 11-7-24 PM - BIE v Planet Energy' is made public 1/2/2025
1/2/2025 Document Served - Other - See Comments - Nature of Service : Email|Eserve; ERRATA SERVED 1/2/25 1/2/2025
1/2/2025 Document Published on Web - Document 'Errata - Rewrite Opinion and Order - 3041126-ALJ - 11-7-24 PM - BIE v Planet Energy' is made public 1/2/2025
1/2/2025 Document Removed from Web - Document 'Rewrite Opinion and Order - 3041126-ALJ - 11-7-24 PM - BIE v Planet Energy' has been removed from Web - {B101B39C-B3FC-CEBE-91D3-93CFCAF00003} 1/2/2025
12/16/2024 Document Served & Pend - Pend for Comments - Nature of Service : N/A; Comments Due 1/15/2025 12/16/2024
12/16/2024 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Rewrite Opinion and Order - 3041126-ALJ - 11-7-24 PM - BIE v Planet Energy' is eServed 12/16/2024
12/16/2024 Document EServed to POR - Document 'VC Barrow Conflict Statement - Planet Energy' is eServed 12/16/2024
12/16/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Rewrite Opinion and Order - 3041126-ALJ - 11-7-24 PM - BIE v Planet Energy' is made public 12/16/2024
12/16/2024 Document Served & Send to C&A - Other - See Comments - Nature of Service : Certified Mail|Email|Eserve; Rewrite Order Served 12/16/2024 See Ordering Paragraph 5 Comments Due 1/15/2025 12/16/2024
11/7/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'VC Barrow Conflict Statement - Planet Energy' is made public 11/7/2024
11/7/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Chairman DeFrank Motion 3041126 ALJ Planet Energy.pdf' is made public 11/7/2024
11/1/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Notice of Appearance - Gray for OSBA' is made public 11/1/2024
11/1/2024 Document Attached to Case - Withdrawal of Appearance - Webb for OSBA - Withdrawal of Appearance filed by Sharon E Webb on behalf of OSBA 11/1/2024
11/1/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Withdrawal of Appearance - Webb for OSBA' is made public 11/1/2024
11/1/2024 Document Attached to Case - Notice of Appearance - Gray for OSBA - Notice of Appearance filed by Steven C Gray on behalf of OSBA 11/1/2024
8/29/2024 Document Served & Pend - Pend for Exceptions - Nature of Service : N/A; EXCEPTIONS DUE 9/18/24, REPLIES DUE 9/30/24 8/29/2024
8/29/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2023-3041126 BIE v Planet Energy ID.pdf' is made public 8/29/2024
8/29/2024 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2023-3041126 BIE v Planet Energy ID.pdf' is eServed 8/29/2024
8/29/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2023-3041126 ID SEC LETTER.pdf' is made public 8/29/2024
8/29/2024 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2023-3041126 ID SEC LETTER.pdf' is eServed 8/29/2024
8/29/2024 Document Served & Send to C&A - Other - See Comments - Nature of Service : Certified Mail|Email|Eserve; ID SERVED 8/29/24, EXCEPTIONS DUE 9/18/24, REPLIES DUE 9/30/24 email and certified mail to POR Sieradzki and Webb 9489009000276604109299 8/29/2024
7/1/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Ltr Opposing Settlement Agreement - OCA' is made public 7/1/2024
7/1/2024 Document Attached to Case - Ltr Opposing Settlement Agreement - OCA - OCA filed letter stating will not be joining in the proposed Joint Petition for Approval of Settlement as OCA does not support the Settlement. 7/1/2024
7/1/2024 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Order Closing the Record.pdf' is eServed 7/1/2024
7/1/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Order Closing the Record.pdf' is made public 7/1/2024
6/6/2024 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Transcript Hrg 1-23-2024 (pg 1-23)' Restricted on Web - {07040272-0670-CF60-8BCC-8FED35900000} 6/6/2024
6/6/2024 Document Attached to Case - Transcript Exhibits Hrg 1-23-2024 - Transcript Exhibits admitted at Hearing held January 23, 2024 filed. 6/6/2024
6/6/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Transcript Exhibits Hrg 1-23-2024' is made public 6/6/2024
6/6/2024 Document Attached to Case - Transcript Hrg 1-23-2024 (pg 1-23) - Initial Call-In Telephonic Hearing before ALJ John M Coogan held Tuesday, January 23, 2024 at 10:15 AM filed. 6/6/2024
6/6/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Withdrawal Request Boyle and Risk - Planet Energy' is made public 6/6/2024
6/6/2024 Document Attached to Case - Withdrawal Request Boyle and Risk - Planet Energy - Withdrawal Request of Brian Boyle, Esq. and Jayne Risk, Esq. on behalf of Planet Energy. 6/6/2024
6/5/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Jnt Petition for Approval of Settlement w/Planet Energy Etc - BIE' is made public 6/5/2024
6/5/2024 Document Attached to Case - Jnt Petition for Approval of Settlement w/Planet Energy Etc - BIE - BIE filed Jnt Petition for Approval of Settlement w/Planet Energy (Pennsylvania) Corp d/b/a RiteRate Energy d/b/a Value Plus Energy & Stmt in Support. 6/5/2024
6/5/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Transcript Exhibits 01-23-2024' is made public 6/5/2024
6/5/2024 Document Attached to Case - Transcript Exhibits 01-23-2024 - Transcript exhibits from hearing held on January 23, 2024 filed. 6/5/2024
5/31/2024 Document Removed from Web - Document 'Transcript Exhibits - 01-23-2024' has been removed from Web - {94038C42-03A8-C350-886A-8D7A92200000} 5/31/2024
5/9/2024 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Settlement and Briefing Order.pdf' is eServed 5/9/2024
5/9/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Settlement and Briefing Order.pdf' is made public 5/9/2024
5/3/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Withdrawal of Testimony for J Small - Planet Energy' is made public 5/3/2024
5/3/2024 Document Attached to Case - Withdrawal of Testimony for J Small - Planet Energy - Planet Energy (Pennsylvania) Corp filed withdrawal of testimony of Jordan Small. 5/3/2024
4/1/2024 Document Attached to Case - Withdrawal of Appearance - Hoover/OCA - OCA filed Withdrawal of Appearance of Christine Maloni Hoover. 4/1/2024
4/1/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Withdrawal of Appearance - Hoover/OCA' is made public 4/1/2024
3/4/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Withdrawal of Appearance - Andreoli/OCA' is made public 3/4/2024
3/4/2024 Document Attached to Case - Withdrawal of Appearance - Andreoli/OCA - Christopher Andreoli filed Withdrawal of Appearance on behalf of OCA. 3/4/2024
2/7/2024 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Transcript Initial Hrg (In Person) 1-23-24 (Pg 1-23)' Restricted on Web - {883AB891-9E91-C8EB-841C-8D803D100000} 2/7/2024
2/7/2024 Document Attached to Case - Transcript Initial Hrg (In Person) 1-23-24 (Pg 1-23) - Initial Hearing (In Person) before ALJ John M. Coogan held January 23, 2024 at 10:15 a.m. filed with exhibits. 2/7/2024
2/7/2024 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Transcript Initial Hrg (In Person) 1-23-24 (Pg 1-23)' Restricted on Web - {4ACABF0F-5943-C812-859A-8D7FEF400000} 2/7/2024
2/7/2024 Document Attached to Case - Transcript Initial Hrg (In Person) 1-23-24 (Pg 1-23) - Initial Hearing (In Person) before ALJ John M. Coogan held January 23, 2024 at 10:15 a.m. filed with exhibits. 2/7/2024
2/6/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Transcript Exhibits - 01-23-2024' is made public 2/6/2024
2/6/2024 Document Attached to Case - Transcript Exhibits - 01-23-2024 - Transcript exhibits to hearing held on January 23, 2024 filed. 2/6/2024
1/22/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Srvc interrog resp to Planet Energy, Set I - OCA' is made public 1/22/2024
1/22/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Srvc interrog req for admission, Set I to Planet Energy - OCA' is made public 1/22/2024
1/22/2024 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Srvc interrog req for admission, Set I to Planet Energy - OCA - Office of Consumer Advocate filed Certificate of Service. 1/22/2024
1/22/2024 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Srvc interrog resp to Planet Energy, Set I - OCA - Planet Energy (Pennsylvania) Corporation filed Certificate of Service. 1/22/2024
1/19/2024 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Type Change Initial Telephonic Hearing Notice.docx' is eServed 1/19/2024
1/19/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Type Change Initial Telephonic Hearing Notice.docx' is made public 1/19/2024
1/19/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Srvc interrog answ Set I to Planet Energy - BIE' is made public 1/19/2024
1/19/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Srvc resp to interrrog Set I to Planet Energy - BIE' is made public 1/19/2024
1/19/2024 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Srvc resp to interrrog Set I to Planet Energy - BIE - PAPUC Bureau of Investigation and Enforcement filed Certificate of Service. 1/19/2024
1/19/2024 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Srvc interrog answ Set I to Planet Energy - BIE - PAPUC Bureau of Investigation and Enforcement filed Certificate of Service. 1/19/2024
1/16/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cvr Ltr & COS to Resp to Intrrg Set I - Planet Energy' is made public 1/16/2024
1/16/2024 Document Attached to Case - Cvr Ltr & COS to Resp to Intrrg Set I - Planet Energy - Planet Energy filed Cover Letter and Certificate of Service to Responses to OCA Interrogatories Set I 1/16/2024
1/12/2024 Document Attached to Case - Cover Ltr & COS Resp & Objections OCA Requests to Admission Set I - Planet Energy - Planet Energy (Pennsylvania) Corp d/b/a RiteRate Energy d/b/a Value Plus Energy filed Cover Ltr & COS Re Resp & Objections to OCA'S Requests to Admission Set I. 1/12/2024
1/12/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cover Ltr & COS Resp & Objections OCA Requests to Admission Set I - Planet Energy' is made public 1/12/2024
1/12/2024 Document Attached to Case - Cover Ltr & COS Interrog - Planet Energy - Planet Energy (Pennsylvania) Corp d/b/a RiteRate Energy d/b/a Value Plus Energy filed Cover Ltr & COS Re Interrog. 1/12/2024
1/12/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cover Ltr & COS Interrog - Planet Energy' is made public 1/12/2024
1/5/2024 Document Attached to Case - Letter/Not Filing Rebuttal Testimony - OSBA - OSBA filed letter stating they will not be submitting rebuttal testimony. 1/5/2024
1/5/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Letter/Not Filing Rebuttal Testimony - OSBA' is made public 1/5/2024
1/5/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Certificate of Service - Pre Served Rebuttal Testimony of BIE' is made public 1/5/2024
1/5/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Certificate of Service- OCA Statement 1R: Rebuttal Testimony of Morgan N DeAngelo' is made public 1/5/2024
1/5/2024 Document Attached to Case - Certificate of Service- OCA Statement 1R: Rebuttal Testimony of Morgan N DeAngelo 1/5/2024
1/5/2024 Document Attached to Case - Certificate of Service - Pre Served Rebuttal Testimony of BIE 1/5/2024
1/4/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Srvc interrog to OCA set I - Planet Energy' is made public 1/4/2024
1/4/2024 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Srvc interrog to OCA set I - Planet Energy - Planet Energy filed Certificate of Service. 1/4/2024
1/4/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Srvc interrog to BIE set I - Planet Energy' is made public 1/4/2024
1/4/2024 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Srvc interrog to BIE set I - Planet Energy - Planet Energy filed Certificate of Service. 1/4/2024
1/4/2024 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Srvc req for admission to OCA set I - Planet Energy - Planet Energy filed Certificate of Service. 1/4/2024
1/4/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Srvc req for admission to OCA set I - Planet Energy' is made public 1/4/2024
1/2/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cvr Ltr & COS to Obj to Intrrg - Planet Energy' is made public 1/2/2024
1/2/2024 Document Attached to Case - Cvr Ltr & COS to Obj to Intrrg - Planet Energy - Planet Energy filed Cover Letter and Certificate of Service to Objections to the Office of Consumer Advocate’s Interrogatories Set I. 1/2/2024
12/28/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Certificate of Service- Requests for admission of Consumer Advocate, set I' is made public 12/28/2023
12/28/2023 Document Attached to Case - Certificate of Service- Requests for admission of Consumer Advocate, set I 12/28/2023
12/20/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Certificate of Service to Set I Interrogs - OCA' is made public 12/20/2023
12/20/2023 Document Attached to Case - Certificate of Service to Set I Interrogs - OCA - OCA filed certificate of service to Set I interrogatories. 12/20/2023
12/12/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Nt of Appr of Swindler & Withdrw of Appr of Rost- BIE' is made public 12/12/2023
12/12/2023 Document Attached to Case - Nt of Appr of Swindler & Withdrw of Appr of Rost- BIE - BIE filed Notice of Appearance of Michael L. Swindler & Withdrawal of Appearance of Kayla L. Rost 12/12/2023
12/6/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2023-3041126 - Order Ending Settlement Judge Procedure.docx' is made public 12/6/2023
12/6/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2023-3041126 - Order Ending Settlement Judge Procedure.docx' is eServed 12/6/2023
12/4/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Srvc Stmt 1 - Planet Energy' is made public 12/4/2023
12/4/2023 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Srvc Stmt 1 - Planet Energy - Planet Energy (Pennsylvania) Corp filed Certificate of Service. 12/4/2023
12/4/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Srvc Stmt 1&2 - BIE' is made public 12/4/2023
12/4/2023 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Srvc Stmt 1 - OCA - Office of Consumer Advocate filed Certificate of Service. 12/4/2023
12/4/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Srvc Stmt 1 - OCA' is made public 12/4/2023
12/4/2023 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Srvc Stmt 1&2 - BIE - PA PUC Bureau of Investigation & Enforcement filed Certificate of Service. 12/4/2023
11/30/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Srvc will not be submitting Direct Testimony - OSBA' is made public 11/30/2023
11/30/2023 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Srvc will not be submitting Direct Testimony - OSBA - Office of Small Business Advocate filed Certificate of Service. 11/30/2023
10/27/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Settlement Judge Order.docx' is eServed 11/8/2023
10/27/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Order Regarding Bankruptcy Briefs.docx' is eServed 11/8/2023
10/27/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Order Regarding Bankruptcy Briefs.docx' is made public 10/27/2023
10/27/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Settlement Judge Order.docx' is made public 10/27/2023
10/23/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Brief on Bankruptcy - I&E' is made public 10/23/2023
10/23/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reply Briefs - Planet Energy' is made public 10/23/2023
10/23/2023 Document Attached to Case - Brief on Bankruptcy - I&E - I&E filed Brief on Bankruptcy. 10/23/2023
10/23/2023 Document Attached to Case - Reply Briefs - Planet Energy - Planet Energy filed Reply Brief. 10/23/2023
10/23/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Brief in Support of Stay - Planet Energy' is made public 10/23/2023
10/23/2023 Document Attached to Case - Brief in Support of Stay - Planet Energy - Planet Energy filed Brief in Support of Stay. 10/23/2023
10/20/2023 Document Attached to Case - Letter in Lieu of a Brief - OCA - Office of Consumer Advocate filed Letter in Lieu of a Brief. 10/20/2023
10/20/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Letter in Lieu of a Brief - OCA' is made public 10/20/2023
10/17/2023 Document Attached to Case - Transcript Initial PHC 9-20-2023 (Pg 1-23) - Initial Prehearing Conference (Call In) before ALJ John M. Coogan held September 20, 2023 at 10:33 a.m. 10/17/2023
10/17/2023 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Transcript Initial PHC 9-20-2023 (Pg 1-23)' Restricted on Web - {62C73277-9FAB-C9A6-8600-8B3A7C400000} 10/17/2023
10/11/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Briefing Order.docx' is eServed - {07FB4791-2FDC-C240-8745-8B1F00B00000} 10/11/2023
10/11/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Briefing Order.docx' is made public 10/11/2023
10/3/2023 Document Attached to Case - Letter/Notice RE Related Proceeding - Planet Energy - Planet Energy (PA) Corp filed notice regarding related proceeding. 10/3/2023
10/3/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Letter/Notice RE Related Proceeding - Planet Energy' is made public 10/3/2023
9/27/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Initial In-Person Hearing Notice' is eServed - {3869CE89-EA86-C959-A91D-8AD77B40000B} 9/27/2023
9/27/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Initial In-Person Hearing Notice' is made public 9/27/2023
9/27/2023 Document Removed from Web - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Initial Telephonic Hearing Notice 2' has been removed from Web - {9B41170D-EC44-CD1A-AE98-8AD733D00006} 9/27/2023
9/27/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Initial Telephonic Hearing Notice 2' is eServed - {9B41170D-EC44-CD1A-AE98-8AD733D00006} 9/27/2023
9/27/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Initial Telephonic Hearing Notice 2' is made public 9/27/2023
9/20/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Scheduling Order.docx' is made public 9/20/2023
9/20/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Scheduling Order.docx' is eServed - {9AF00C0E-C0AD-C862-87AB-8AB443400000} 9/20/2023
9/19/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Prehearing Memorandum - OCA' is made public 9/19/2023
9/19/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Prehearing Memorandum - Planet Energy' is made public 9/19/2023
9/19/2023 Document Attached to Case - Prehearing Memorandum - OCA - Office of Consumer Advocate filed Prehearing Memorandum. 9/19/2023
9/19/2023 Document Attached to Case - Prehearing Memorandum - Planet Energy - Planet Energy (Pennsylvania) Corporation filed Prehearing Memorandum. 9/19/2023
9/18/2023 Document Attached to Case - Prehearing Conference Memorandum - BIE - BIE filed Prehearing Conference Memorandum. 9/18/2023
9/18/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Prehearing Conference Memorandum - BIE' is made public 9/18/2023
9/18/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Prehearing Memorandum - OSBA' is made public 9/18/2023
9/18/2023 Document Attached to Case - Prehearing Memorandum - OSBA - OSBA filed Prehearing Memorandum. 9/18/2023
7/31/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Continuance Order.docx' is eServed - {F087C461-BDA0-C224-841D-89AC71600000} 7/31/2023
7/31/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Continuance Order.docx' is made public 7/31/2023
7/28/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Initial Call In Telephonic Prehearing Conference Notice.docx' is eServed - {7E646236-6D51-C3B0-8596-899DAAB00000} 7/28/2023
7/28/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Initial Call In Telephonic Prehearing Conference Notice.docx' is made public 7/28/2023
7/27/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Hearing Cancellation Notice.docx' is eServed - {D93C30E1-AEBA-C588-8AEE-8997F5800005} 7/27/2023
7/27/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Hearing Cancellation Notice.docx' is made public 7/27/2023
7/27/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Amended Cert of Srvc - Planet Energy' is made public 7/27/2023
7/27/2023 Document Attached to Case - Amended Cert of Srvc - Planet Energy - Planet Energy filed Amended Certificate of Service. 7/27/2023
7/26/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Notice of Appearance - Jayne A Risk for Planet Energy' is made public 7/26/2023
7/26/2023 Document Attached to Case - Notice of Appearance - Jayne A Risk for Planet Energy - Notice of Appearance of Jayne A Risk on behalf of Planet Energy (Pennsylvania) Corp d/b/a RiteRate Energy d/b/a Value Plus Energy filed. 7/26/2023
7/25/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Motion for Continuance - Planet Energy' is made public 7/25/2023
7/25/2023 Document Attached to Case - Motion for Continuance - Planet Energy - Planet Energy (Pennsylvania) Corp filed motion for 30 day continuance of prehearing. 7/25/2023
7/25/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Notice of Appearance - Brian J Boyle for Planet Energy' is made public 7/25/2023
7/25/2023 Document Attached to Case - Notice of Appearance - Brian J Boyle for Planet Energy - Notice of Appearance of Brian J Boyle on behalf of Planet Energy Corporation filed. 7/25/2023
7/25/2023 Document Attached to Case - Notice of Intervention - OSBA - Office of Small Business Advocate filed Notice of Intervention 7/25/2023
7/25/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Notice of Intervention - OSBA' is made public 7/25/2023
7/24/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Notice of Appearance - Sharon E Webb for OSBA' is made public 7/24/2023
7/24/2023 Document Attached to Case - Notice of Appearance - Sharon E Webb for OSBA - Notice of Appearance of Sharon E Webb on behalf of OSBA filed. 7/24/2023
7/19/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Re-served BIE Complaint Notice - BIE vs Planet Energy (PA).docx' is made public 7/19/2023
7/19/2023 Re-Served & Close Task - Undeliverable as Addressed - Re-served Formal complaint to Planet Energy (Pennsylvania) Corp due to addres correction, Answer due in 20 day. 7/19/2023
7/19/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Returned Mail Envelope - BIE vs Planet Energy (Pennsylvania)' is made public 7/19/2023
7/19/2023 Document Attached to Case - Returned Mail Envelope - BIE vs Planet Energy (Pennsylvania) - Returned certified mail received Returned to Sender. 7/19/2023
7/13/2023 Document Attached to Case - Notice of Intervention - OCA - Office of Consumer Advocate filed Notice of Intervention and Public Statement. 7/13/2023
7/13/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Notice of Intervention - OCA' is made public 7/13/2023
6/22/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Prehearing Order.docx' is eServed - {6A87F082-4364-C131-84EA-88E373400000} 6/22/2023
6/22/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Prehearing Order.docx' is made public 6/22/2023
6/21/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Initial Call In Telephonic Hearing Notice.docx' is eServed - {908D757A-3C70-C202-9263-88DEB5100000} 6/21/2023
6/21/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2023-3041126 Initial Call In Telephonic Hearing Notice.docx' is made public 6/21/2023
6/20/2023 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer to Formal Complaint - Planet Energy' Restricted on Web - {4E9594C3-61F5-C9AF-84F1-88D3D4900000} 6/20/2023
6/20/2023 Document Attached to Case - Answer to Formal Complaint - Planet Energy - Planet Energy (Pennsylvania) Corp d/b/a RiteRate Energy d/b/a Value Plus Energy filed Answer to Formal complaint of BIE. 6/20/2023
6/6/2023 Document Served - Other - See Comments - Assigned to ALJ. 6/6/2023
6/6/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'BIE vs Planet Energy (Pennsylvania) Corp FC' is eServed - {E980AFB2-4DA1-C0E0-87D0-8877FDD00000} 6/6/2023
6/6/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'BIE Complaint Notice - BIE vs Planet Energy (PA)' is eServed - {EEEEC8D6-328B-C90D-86CE-8890E0900000} 6/6/2023
6/6/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'BIE Complaint Notice - BIE vs Planet Energy (PA)' is made public 6/6/2023
6/6/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'BIE vs Planet Energy (Pennsylvania) Corp FC' is made public 6/6/2023
6/6/2023 Assigned Responsible Bureau - ALJ 6/6/2023
6/6/2023 Case Created - C-2023-3041126 - BIE complaint against Planet Energy (Pennsylvania) Corp d/b/a RiteRate Energy d/b/a Value Plus Energy 6/6/2023
Public Documents
Document Name Document Type eFiling Confirmation Number Date Received Post On Date Date Served Reference Docket Number
COMMENTS - BIE Comments 2477393 1/15/2025 1/15/2025 C-2023-3041126
ERRATA - REWRITE OPINION AND ORDER - 3041126-ALJ - 11-7-24 PM - BIE V PLANET ENERGY Errata 2477393 1/2/2025 1/2/2025 C-2023-3041126
REWRITE OPINION AND ORDER - 3041126-ALJ - 11-7-24 PM - BIE V PLANET ENERGY Order 2477393 1/2/2025 12/16/2024 C-2023-3041126
CHAIRMAN DEFRANK MOTION 3041126 ALJ PLANET ENERGY.PDF Motion 2477393 11/7/2024 C-2023-3041126
VC BARROW CONFLICT STATEMENT - PLANET ENERGY Statement 2477393 11/7/2024 C-2023-3041126
WITHDRAWAL OF APPEARANCE - WEBB FOR OSBA Withdrawal Request 2477393 11/1/2024 11/1/2024 C-2023-3041126
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE - GRAY FOR OSBA Notice of Appearance 2477393 11/1/2024 11/1/2024 C-2023-3041126
C-2023-3041126 ID SEC LETTER.PDF Secretarial Letter 2477393 8/29/2024 8/29/2024 C-2023-3041126
C-2023-3041126 BIE V PLANET ENERGY ID.PDF Initial Decision 2477393 8/29/2024 8/29/2024 C-2023-3041126
LTR OPPOSING SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT - OCA Letter 2477393 6/28/2024 7/1/2024 C-2023-3041126
C-2023-3041126 ORDER CLOSING THE RECORD.PDF Order 2477393 7/1/2024 C-2023-3041126
TRANSCRIPT EXHIBITS HRG 1-23-2024 Transcript Exhibit 2477393 6/6/2024 6/6/2024 C-2023-3041126
WITHDRAWAL REQUEST BOYLE AND RISK - PLANET ENERGY Withdrawal Request 2477393 6/5/2024 6/6/2024 C-2023-3041126
JNT PETITION FOR APPROVAL OF SETTLEMENT W/PLANET ENERGY ETC - BIE Settlement Agreement 2477393 6/5/2024 6/5/2024 C-2023-3041126
TRANSCRIPT EXHIBITS 01-23-2024 Transcript Exhibit 2477393 6/4/2024 6/5/2024 C-2023-3041126
C-2023-3041126 SETTLEMENT AND BRIEFING ORDER.PDF Order 2477393 5/9/2024 C-2023-3041126
WITHDRAWAL OF TESTIMONY FOR J SMALL - PLANET ENERGY Withdrawal Request 2477393 5/1/2024 5/3/2024 C-2023-3041126
WITHDRAWAL OF APPEARANCE - HOOVER/OCA Withdrawal Request 2477393 3/29/2024 4/1/2024 C-2023-3041126
WITHDRAWAL OF APPEARANCE - ANDREOLI/OCA Withdrawal Request 2477393 2/29/2024 3/4/2024 C-2023-3041126
CERT OF SRVC INTERROG REQ FOR ADMISSION, SET I TO PLANET ENERGY - OCA Certificate of Service 2477393 1/22/2024 1/22/2024 C-2023-3041126
CERT OF SRVC INTERROG RESP TO PLANET ENERGY, SET I - OCA Certificate of Service 2477393 1/22/2024 1/22/2024 C-2023-3041126
C-2023-3041126 TYPE CHANGE INITIAL TELEPHONIC HEARING NOTICE.DOCX Hearing Notice 2477393 1/19/2024 C-2023-3041126
CERT OF SRVC RESP TO INTERRROG SET I TO PLANET ENERGY - BIE Certificate of Service 2477393 1/19/2024 1/19/2024 C-2023-3041126
CERT OF SRVC INTERROG ANSW SET I TO PLANET ENERGY - BIE Certificate of Service 2477393 1/19/2024 1/19/2024 C-2023-3041126
CVR LTR & COS TO RESP TO INTRRG SET I - PLANET ENERGY Letter 2477393 1/16/2024 1/16/2024 C-2023-3041126
COVER LTR & COS RESP & OBJECTIONS OCA REQUESTS TO ADMISSION SET I - PLANET ENERGY Certificate of Service 2477393 1/8/2024 1/12/2024 C-2023-3041126
COVER LTR & COS INTERROG - PLANET ENERGY Certificate of Service 2477393 1/2/2024 1/12/2024 C-2023-3041126
LETTER/NOT FILING REBUTTAL TESTIMONY - OSBA Letter 2477393 1/4/2024 1/5/2024 C-2023-3041126
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE- OCA STATEMENT 1R: REBUTTAL TESTIMONY OF MORGAN N DEANGELO Certificate of Service 2477393 1/4/2024 1/5/2024 C-2023-3041126
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE - PRE SERVED REBUTTAL TESTIMONY OF BIE Certificate of Service 2477393 1/4/2024 1/5/2024 C-2023-3041126
CERT OF SRVC INTERROG TO OCA SET I - PLANET ENERGY Certificate of Service 2477393 1/2/2024 1/4/2024 C-2023-3041126
CERT OF SRVC INTERROG TO BIE SET I - PLANET ENERGY Certificate of Service 2477393 1/2/2024 1/4/2024 C-2023-3041126
CERT OF SRVC REQ FOR ADMISSION TO OCA SET I - PLANET ENERGY Certificate of Service 2477393 1/2/2024 1/4/2024 C-2023-3041126
CVR LTR & COS TO OBJ TO INTRRG - PLANET ENERGY Letter 2477393 12/29/2023 1/2/2024 C-2023-3041126
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE- REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION OF CONSUMER ADVOCATE, SET I Certificate of Service 2477393 12/27/2023 12/28/2023 C-2023-3041126
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE TO SET I INTERROGS - OCA Certificate of Service 2477393 12/19/2023 12/20/2023 C-2023-3041126
NT OF APPR OF SWINDLER & WITHDRW OF APPR OF ROST- BIE Notice of Appearance 2477393 12/11/2023 12/12/2023 C-2023-3041126
C-2023-3041126 - ORDER ENDING SETTLEMENT JUDGE PROCEDURE.DOCX Order 2477393 12/6/2023 C-2023-3041126
CERT OF SRVC STMT 1 - PLANET ENERGY Certificate of Service 2477393 12/1/2023 12/4/2023 C-2023-3041126
CERT OF SRVC STMT 1 - OCA Certificate of Service 2477393 11/30/2023 12/4/2023 C-2023-3041126
CERT OF SRVC STMT 1&2 - BIE Certificate of Service 2477393 11/30/2023 12/4/2023 C-2023-3041126
CERT OF SRVC WILL NOT BE SUBMITTING DIRECT TESTIMONY - OSBA Certificate of Service 2477393 11/30/2023 11/30/2023 C-2023-3041126
C-2023-3041126 ORDER REGARDING BANKRUPTCY BRIEFS.DOCX Order 2477393 10/27/2023 C-2023-3041126
C-2023-3041126 SETTLEMENT JUDGE ORDER.DOCX Order 2477393 10/27/2023 C-2023-3041126
REPLY BRIEFS - PLANET ENERGY Briefs 2477393 10/20/2023 10/23/2023 C-2023-3041126
BRIEF ON BANKRUPTCY - I&E Briefs 2477393 10/19/2023 10/23/2023 C-2023-3041126
BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF STAY - PLANET ENERGY Briefs 2477393 10/19/2023 10/23/2023 C-2023-3041126
LETTER IN LIEU OF A BRIEF - OCA Letter 2477393 10/19/2023 10/20/2023 C-2023-3041126
C-2023-3041126 BRIEFING ORDER.DOCX Order 2477393 10/11/2023 C-2023-3041126
LETTER/NOTICE RE RELATED PROCEEDING - PLANET ENERGY Letter 2477393 10/2/2023 10/3/2023 C-2023-3041126
C-2023-3041126 INITIAL IN-PERSON HEARING NOTICE Hearing Notice 2477393 9/27/2023 C-2023-3041126
C-2023-3041126 SCHEDULING ORDER.DOCX Order 2477393 9/20/2023 C-2023-3041126
PREHEARING MEMORANDUM - OCA Prehearing Memorandum 2477393 9/18/2023 9/19/2023 C-2023-3041126
PREHEARING MEMORANDUM - PLANET ENERGY Prehearing Memorandum 2477393 9/18/2023 9/19/2023 C-2023-3041126
PREHEARING CONFERENCE MEMORANDUM - BIE Prehearing Memorandum 2477393 9/15/2023 9/18/2023 C-2023-3041126
PREHEARING MEMORANDUM - OSBA Prehearing Memorandum 2477393 9/15/2023 9/18/2023 C-2023-3041126
C-2023-3041126 CONTINUANCE ORDER.DOCX Order 2477393 7/31/2023 C-2023-3041126
C-2023-3041126 INITIAL CALL IN TELEPHONIC PREHEARING CONFERENCE NOTICE.DOCX Hearing Notice 2477393 7/28/2023 C-2023-3041126
C-2023-3041126 HEARING CANCELLATION NOTICE.DOCX Hearing Cancellation Notice 2477393 7/27/2023 C-2023-3041126
C-2023-3041126 HEARING CANCELLATION NOTICE.DOCX Hearing Cancellation Notice 7/27/2023 C-2023-3041126
AMENDED CERT OF SRVC - PLANET ENERGY Certificate of Service 2477393 7/26/2023 7/27/2023 C-2023-3041126
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE - JAYNE A RISK FOR PLANET ENERGY Notice of Appearance 2477393 7/26/2023 7/26/2023 C-2023-3041126
MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE - PLANET ENERGY Motion 2477393 7/25/2023 7/25/2023 C-2023-3041126
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE - BRIAN J BOYLE FOR PLANET ENERGY Notice of Appearance 2477393 7/25/2023 7/25/2023 C-2023-3041126
NOTICE OF INTERVENTION - OSBA Notice of Intervention 2477393 7/24/2023 7/25/2023 C-2023-3041126
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE - SHARON E WEBB FOR OSBA Notice of Appearance 2477393 7/24/2023 7/24/2023 C-2023-3041126
RE-SERVED BIE COMPLAINT NOTICE - BIE VS PLANET ENERGY (PA).DOCX Secretarial Letter 2477393 7/19/2023 C-2023-3041126
RETURNED MAIL ENVELOPE - BIE VS PLANET ENERGY (PENNSYLVANIA) Returned Mail Envelope 2477393 7/12/2023 7/19/2023 C-2023-3041126
NOTICE OF INTERVENTION - OCA Notice of Intervention 2477393 7/13/2023 7/13/2023 C-2023-3041126
C-2023-3041126 PREHEARING ORDER.DOCX PreHearing Order 2477393 6/22/2023 C-2023-3041126
C-2023-3041126 INITIAL CALL IN TELEPHONIC HEARING NOTICE.DOCX Hearing Notice 2477393 6/21/2023 C-2023-3041126
BIE COMPLAINT NOTICE - BIE VS PLANET ENERGY (PA) Secretarial Letter 2477393 6/6/2023 6/6/2023 C-2023-3041126
BIE VS PLANET ENERGY (PENNSYLVANIA) CORP FC BIE Complaint 2477393 6/1/2023 6/6/2023 C-2023-3041126

 

Need More Help?

If you can't find what you're looking for here, please contact the PA Public Utility Commission. Call us at 1-800-692-7380 or contact us online.

Document Search

Public utility documents available electronically include case dockets, public meeting orders and more.

Document Search

Filing & Resources

Find utility-related reports, laws and regulations, federal filings, tariffs, procedures and more.

Filing & Resources

eFILING

Consumers, utilities and attorneys can save time by submitting documents to the PUC electronically.

Get Details

Customer Hotline 1-800-692-7380

© PUC All Rights Reserved