Skip to content

Docket Number C-2016-2570929

Case Summary
Docket Number C-2016-2570929 Status Closed
Applicant Utility Code 500090
Complainant A EDWARD SCHWARTZ Utility Name DELAWARE AND HUDSON RAILWAY CO.
Respondent DELAWARE AND HUDSON RAILWAY COMPANY Utility Type Railroad
Responsible Bureau OSA eFiling Confirmation Number
Date Filed 09/21/2016 Date Posted 10/12/2016
Case Description A. Edward Schwartz v. Delaware and Hudson Railway Company
Daily Actions
Action Date Description Date Posted
9/6/2018 Case Closed - No active tasks exist for this Case 9/6/2018
4/23/2018 Document EServed to POR - Document '2570929-OSA - Schwartz v NS Railway (NK) Conflict Statement - 4-5-18.pdf' is eServed - {72484A48-CA86-CBA9-8584-629657000000} 4/23/2018
4/23/2018 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Rewrite Opinion and Order - OSA-2570929 - 4-5-18 PM - A Edward Schwartz v Norfolk Southern et al - Exceptions to RD' is eServed - {7FF0399B-A52F-C415-8556-62F335300000} 4/23/2018
4/23/2018 Document Published on Web - Document 'Rewrite Opinion and Order - OSA-2570929 - 4-5-18 PM - A Edward Schwartz v Norfolk Southern et al - Exceptions to RD' is made public 4/23/2018
4/23/2018 Document Served - Other - See Comments - REWRITE ORDER ENTERED 4/23/18 4/23/2018
4/5/2018 Document Published on Web - Document '2570929-OSA - Schwartz v NS Railway (NK) Conflict Statement - 4-5-18.pdf' is made public 4/5/2018
4/5/2018 Document Published on Web - Document 'Commissioner Sweet Vice Chairman Place Joint Motion A Edward Schwartz v Norfolk Southern et al 2570929 OSA.pdf' is made public 4/5/2018
5/23/2017 Document Attached to Case - Reply Exception - Norfolk Southern Railway Co - Norfolk Southern Railway Company filed Reply Exceptions. 5/23/2017
5/23/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reply Exception - Norfolk Southern Railway Co' is made public 5/23/2017
5/18/2017 Document Attached to Case - Motion Strike Exceptions A Edward Schwartz & Replies-PennDOT - PennDOT filed Motion to Strike Exceptions of A .Edward Schwartz and in the alternative, Reply to Exceptions of A. Edward Schwartz. 5/18/2017
5/18/2017 Document Attached to Case - Motion to Strike Exceptions & Replies of A Edward Schwartz-PennDOT - PennDOT filed Motion to Strike Exceptions of A. Edward Schwartz and in the alternative the Replies. 5/18/2017
5/18/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Motion to Strike Exceptions & Replies of A Edward Schwartz-PennDOT' is made public 5/18/2017
5/11/2017 Document Attached to Case - Exceptions - A. Edward Schwartz - A. Edward Schwartz filed Exceptions. 5/11/2017
5/11/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Exceptions - A. Edward Schwartz' is made public 5/11/2017
4/21/2017 Document Served & Send to C&A - Other - See Comments - Recommended Decision served 4/21/17. 4/21/2017
4/21/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'RD Letter C-2016-2570929.doc' is made public 4/21/2017
4/21/2017 Document Served & Pend - Pend for Exceptions - Exceptions Due 5/11/17 - Replies Due 5/22/17. 4/21/2017
4/21/2017 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2016-2570929 A Edward Schwartz v Delaware and Hudson Railway Company RD.pdf' is eServed - {942C428A-99A7-4C2C-B116-7FE035165375} 4/21/2017
4/21/2017 Document EServed to POR - Document 'RD Letter C-2016-2570929.doc' is eServed - {D6BF07C8-CF90-40B7-975F-4D7FF6D4ADDB} 4/21/2017
4/21/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2016-2570929 A Edward Schwartz v Delaware and Hudson Railway Company RD.pdf' is made public 4/21/2017
4/12/2017 Document Attached to Case - Answer to Motion of Norfolk Southern - Schwartz - A. Edward Schwartz filed Answers to Motions for Summary Judgment of Norfolk Southern Railway Company and Pennsylvania Department of Transportation. 4/12/2017
4/12/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer to Motion of PennDOT - Schwartz' is made public 4/12/2017
4/12/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer to Motion of Norfolk Southern - Schwartz' is made public 4/12/2017
4/12/2017 Document Attached to Case - Answer to Motion of PennDOT - Schwartz - A. Edward Schwartz filed Answers to Motions for Summary Judgment of Norfolk Southern Railway Company and Pennsylvania Department of Transportation. 4/12/2017
4/7/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer to Motion for Summary Judgment - Norfolk Southern Railway Co' is made public 4/7/2017
4/7/2017 Document Attached to Case - Notice of Joinder in Norfolk Southerns Answer to Motion for Summary Judgment - LaPlume Twp - LaPlume Township filed notice of joinder in Norfolk Southern Railway Company's answer to motion for summary judgment. 4/7/2017
4/7/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer to Motion for Summary Judgment - PENNDOT' is made public 4/7/2017
4/7/2017 Document Attached to Case - Answer to Motion for Summary Judgment - PENNDOT - PENNDOT filed answer to motion for summary judgment. 4/7/2017
4/7/2017 Document Attached to Case - Notice of Joinder in PENNDOT Answer to Motion for Summary Judgment - Lackawanna County - Lackawanna County filed notice of joinder in PENNDOT's answer to motion for summary judgment. 4/7/2017
4/7/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Notice of Joinder in PENNDOT Answer to Motion for Summary Judgment - Lackawanna County' is made public 4/7/2017
4/7/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Notice of Joinder in Norfolk Southerns Answer to Motion for Summary Judgment - LaPlume Twp' is made public 4/7/2017
4/7/2017 Document Attached to Case - Answer to Motion for Summary Judgment - Norfolk Southern Railway Co - Norfolk Southern Railway Company filed answer to motion for summary judgment. 4/7/2017
3/24/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Motion for Summary Judgment - Schwartz' is made public 3/24/2017
3/24/2017 Document Attached to Case - Motion for Summary Judgment - Schwartz - A. Edward Schwartz filed Motion for Summary Judgment as to PUC jurisdiction over application for determinations as to compensation for damages sustained due to abolition of railroad crossing. 3/24/2017
3/13/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGEMENT - NORFOLK SOUTHERN' is made public 3/13/2017
3/13/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGEMENT - LAPLUME TOWNSHIP' is made public 3/13/2017
3/13/2017 Document Attached to Case - MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGEMENT - LAPLUME TOWNSHIP - LAPLUME TOWNSHIP FILED MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGEMENT 3/13/2017
3/13/2017 Document Attached to Case - MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGEMENT - NORFOLK SOUTHERN - MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGEMENT FILED BY NORFOLK SOUTHERN 3/13/2017
3/8/2017 Document Attached to Case - Joinder in Motion for Summary Judgment - Lackawanna County - Lackawanna County filed Joinder in Motion for Summary Judgment. 3/8/2017
3/8/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Motion for Summary Judgment - Jennifer Brown-Sweeney' is made public 3/8/2017
3/8/2017 Document Attached to Case - Motion for Summary Judgment - Jennifer Brown-Sweeney - Jennifer Brown-Sweeney Assistant Counsel filed Notice of Appearance on behalf of PennDOT and Motion for Summary Judgment. 3/8/2017
3/8/2017 Document Attached to Case - Notice of Appearance for PennDOT - Jennifer Brown-Sweeney - Jennifer Brown-Sweeney Assistant Counsel filed Notice of Appearance on behalf of PennDOT and Motion for Summary Judgment. 3/8/2017
3/8/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Joinder in Motion for Summary Judgment - Lackawanna County' is made public 3/8/2017
3/8/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Notice of Appearance for PennDOT - Jennifer Brown-Sweeney' is made public 3/8/2017
2/17/2017 Document Attached to Case - Electronic Transcript - Hrg 2/8/2017 (pgs 1-16) - Initial Telephonic Hearing w/ALJ Salapa held February 8, 2017 at 10:07 a.m. 2/17/2017
2/17/2017 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Electronic Transcript - Hrg 2/8/2017 (pgs 1-16)' Restricted on Web - {1645E76A-928C-4B0B-96A5-7FB3C87B1A6C} 2/17/2017
2/15/2017 Document Attached to Case - Prehearing Conference Memorandum - Norfolk Southern Railway Co - Norfolk Southern Railway Company filed prehearing conference memorandum. 2/15/2017
2/15/2017 Document Attached to Case - Prehearing Conference Memorandum - A Edward Schwartz - A Edward Schwartz filed prehearing conference memorandum. 2/15/2017
2/15/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Prehearing Conference Memorandum - A Edward Schwartz' is made public 2/15/2017
2/15/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Prehearing Conference Memorandum - Norfolk Southern Railway Co' is made public 2/15/2017
2/13/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Objection & Pre-Hearing Conference Memorandum-Lackawanna' is made public 2/13/2017
2/13/2017 Document Attached to Case - Objection & Pre-Hearing Conference Memorandum-Lackawanna - Lackawanna filed Objection & Pre-Hearing Conference Memorandum 2/13/2017
2/9/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2016-2570929 summary judgment order.pdf' is made public 2/9/2017
2/9/2017 Document Attached to Case - Objections to Pre-Hearing Conference et al-Lackawanna - Lackawanna filed Objections to Pre-Hearing Conference Call et al 2/9/2017
2/9/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Objections to Pre-Hearing Conference et al-Lackawanna' is made public 2/9/2017
2/9/2017 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2016-2570929 summary judgment order.pdf' is eServed - {CC849606-9EA7-4566-BC5E-5A7317DCBD0F} 2/9/2017
2/6/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Prehearing Memo - Norfolk Southern' is made public 2/6/2017
2/6/2017 Document Attached to Case - Prehearing Memo - Norfolk Southern - Norfolk Southern Railway Company filed prehearing memorandum. 2/6/2017
2/1/2017 Document Attached to Case - Prehearing Memorandum - PENNDOT - The Commonwealth Of Pennsylvania's Department of Transportation filed Prehearing Memorandum. 2/1/2017
2/1/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Prehearing Memorandum - PENNDOT' is made public 2/1/2017
1/19/2017 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2016-2570929 Prehearing conference order.pdf' is eServed - {8AC1E8AC-06AD-4DAF-AFED-3A883CC61DA4} 1/19/2017
1/19/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2016-2570929 Prehearing conference order.pdf' is made public 1/19/2017
1/18/2017 Document Attached to Case - Reply to Answer - A Edward schwartz - A. Edward Schwartz filed reply to answer. 1/18/2017
1/18/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reply to Answer - A Edward schwartz' is made public 1/18/2017
1/4/2017 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2016-2570929 Initial Call In Telephonic Prehearing Conference.docx' is eServed - {6B34DA97-F0AC-400C-944B-4F08D3D072F1} 1/4/2017
1/4/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2016-2570929 Initial Call In Telephonic Prehearing Conference.docx' is made public 1/4/2017
12/29/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Entry of Appearance of D Gromelski - LaPlume Township' is made public 12/29/2016
12/29/2016 Document Attached to Case - Answer & New Matter to Formal Complaint - LaPlume Township - LaPlume Township filed answer and new matter to formal complaint. 12/29/2016
12/29/2016 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer & New Matter to Formal Complaint - LaPlume Township' Restricted on Web - {A6C962F4-A946-44E7-A508-16563DA3A3D4} 12/29/2016
12/29/2016 Document Attached to Case - Entry of Appearance of D Gromelski - LaPlume Township - LaPlume Township filed entry of appearance of David J Gromelski. 12/29/2016
12/20/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reply to New Matter - A Edward Schwartz' is made public 12/20/2016
12/20/2016 Document Attached to Case - Reply to New Matter - A Edward Schwartz - A Edward Schwartz filed reply to new matter. 12/20/2016
12/12/2016 Document Attached to Case - Reply to New Matter - Norfolk Southern Railway - Norfolk Southern Railway Co filed reply to new matter. 12/12/2016
12/12/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reply to New Matter - Norfolk Southern Railway' is made public 12/12/2016
12/8/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reply to PennDOT New Matter - A Edward Schwartz' is made public 12/8/2016
12/8/2016 Document Attached to Case - Reply to PennDOT New Matter - A Edward Schwartz - A. Edward Schwartz filed Answer to PennDOT's New Matter. 12/8/2016
12/1/2016 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Amended Answer to Complaint & New Matter-Lackawanna' Restricted on Web - {4656B2CE-BD20-424D-877C-F30590B33233} 12/1/2016
12/1/2016 Document Attached to Case - Notice of Appearance-Frederickson for Lackawanna Cnty - Donald J Frederickson filed Notice of Appearance & Amended Answer to Complaint & New Matter for Lackawanna Cnty 12/1/2016
12/1/2016 Document Attached to Case - Amended Answer to Complaint & New Matter-Lackawanna - Donald J Frederickson filed Notice of Appearance & Amended Answer to Complaint & New Matter for Lackawanna Cnty 12/1/2016
12/1/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Notice of Appearance-Frederickson for Lackawanna Cnty' is made public 12/1/2016
11/21/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Notice of Appearance - Dunlap/Norfolk Southern' is made public 11/21/2016
11/21/2016 Document Attached to Case - Answer & New Matter to Formal Complaint - Norfolk Southern - Norfolk Southern Railway Company filed Answer and New to the formal complaint of A Edward Schwartz. 11/21/2016
11/21/2016 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer & New Matter to Formal Complaint - Norfolk Southern' Restricted on Web - {4905CC86-015A-425D-9780-AC1409BA9A03} 11/21/2016
11/21/2016 Document Attached to Case - Notice of Appearance - Dunlap/Norfolk Southern - Notice of Appearance of Benjamin C. Dunlap Jr. on behalf of Norfolk Southern Railway Company filed. 11/21/2016
11/15/2016 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer & New Matter - PennDOT' Restricted on Web - {BCE2B0F3-EAC9-454C-BC73-C5A50F48BF93} 11/15/2016
11/15/2016 Document Attached to Case - Answer & New Matter - PennDOT - Pennsylvania Department of Transportation filed Answer and New Matter to Formal Complaint of A. Edward Schwartz. 11/15/2016
10/31/2016 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Reserved Formal Complaint Notice' is eServed - {FAE8BEF0-BBFC-4E39-A1F0-5997A6727DFF} 10/31/2016
10/31/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reserved Formal Complaint Notice' is made public 10/31/2016
10/12/2016 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Formal Complaint' Restricted on Web - {054A5126-2CDC-4CD7-942B-186370D64038} 10/12/2016
10/12/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Schwartz v D&H RR FC Notice' is made public 10/12/2016
10/12/2016 Document Served - Other - See Comments - Assigned to TUS RR, Notification to LAW. 10/12/2016
10/12/2016 Case Created - C-2016-2570929 - Railroad Complaint filed. 10/12/2016
10/12/2016 Assigned Responsible Bureau - TUS 10/12/2016
Public Documents
Document Name Document Type eFiling Confirmation Number Date Received Post On Date Date Served Reference Docket Number
REWRITE OPINION AND ORDER - OSA-2570929 - 4-5-18 PM - A EDWARD SCHWARTZ V NORFOLK SOUTHERN ET AL - EXCEPTIONS TO RD Order 4/23/2018 4/23/2018 C-2016-2570929
2570929-OSA - SCHWARTZ V NS RAILWAY (NK) CONFLICT STATEMENT - 4-5-18.PDF Statement 4/5/2018 C-2016-2570929
COMMISSIONER SWEET VICE CHAIRMAN PLACE JOINT MOTION A EDWARD SCHWARTZ V NORFOLK SOUTHERN ET AL 2570929 OSA.PDF Motion 4/5/2018 C-2016-2570929
REPLY EXCEPTION - NORFOLK SOUTHERN RAILWAY CO Reply Exception 5/22/2017 5/23/2017 C-2016-2570929
MOTION TO STRIKE EXCEPTIONS & REPLIES OF A EDWARD SCHWARTZ-PENNDOT Motion 5/18/2017 5/18/2017 C-2016-2570929
MOTION STRIKE EXCEPTIONS A EDWARD SCHWARTZ & REPLIES-PENNDOT Motion 5/18/2017 5/18/2017 C-2016-2570929
EXCEPTIONS - A. EDWARD SCHWARTZ Exceptions 5/9/2017 5/11/2017 C-2016-2570929
C-2016-2570929 A EDWARD SCHWARTZ V DELAWARE AND HUDSON RAILWAY COMPANY RD.PDF Recommended Decision 4/21/2017 4/21/2017 C-2016-2570929
RD LETTER C-2016-2570929.DOC Secretarial Letter 4/21/2017 4/21/2017 C-2016-2570929
ANSWER TO MOTION OF NORFOLK SOUTHERN - SCHWARTZ Answer to Motion 4/5/2017 4/12/2017 C-2016-2570929
ANSWER TO MOTION OF PENNDOT - SCHWARTZ Answer to Motion 4/5/2017 4/12/2017 C-2016-2570929
NOTICE OF JOINDER IN NORFOLK SOUTHERNS ANSWER TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT - LAPLUME TWP Answer to Motion 4/7/2017 4/7/2017 C-2016-2570929
NOTICE OF JOINDER IN PENNDOT ANSWER TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT - LACKAWANNA COUNTY Answer to Motion 4/7/2017 4/7/2017 C-2016-2570929
ANSWER TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT - PENNDOT Answer to Motion 4/7/2017 4/7/2017 C-2016-2570929
ANSWER TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT - NORFOLK SOUTHERN RAILWAY CO Answer to Motion 4/7/2017 4/7/2017 C-2016-2570929
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT - SCHWARTZ Motion 3/9/2017 3/24/2017 C-2016-2570929
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGEMENT - LAPLUME TOWNSHIP Motion 3/13/2017 3/13/2017 C-2016-2570929
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGEMENT - NORFOLK SOUTHERN Motion 3/13/2017 3/13/2017 C-2016-2570929
JOINDER IN MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT - LACKAWANNA COUNTY Motion 3/8/2017 3/8/2017 C-2016-2570929
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE FOR PENNDOT - JENNIFER BROWN-SWEENEY Notice of Appearance 3/7/2017 3/8/2017 C-2016-2570929
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT - JENNIFER BROWN-SWEENEY Motion 3/7/2017 3/8/2017 C-2016-2570929
PREHEARING CONFERENCE MEMORANDUM - NORFOLK SOUTHERN RAILWAY CO Prehearing Memorandum 2/8/2017 2/15/2017 C-2016-2570929
PREHEARING CONFERENCE MEMORANDUM - A EDWARD SCHWARTZ Prehearing Memorandum 2/6/2017 2/15/2017 C-2016-2570929
OBJECTION & PRE-HEARING CONFERENCE MEMORANDUM-LACKAWANNA Prehearing Memorandum 2/13/2017 2/13/2017 C-2016-2570929
C-2016-2570929 SUMMARY JUDGMENT ORDER.PDF PreHearing Order 2/9/2017 C-2016-2570929
OBJECTIONS TO PRE-HEARING CONFERENCE ET AL-LACKAWANNA Case Related Document 2/9/2017 2/9/2017 C-2016-2570929
PREHEARING MEMO - NORFOLK SOUTHERN Prehearing Memorandum 2/6/2017 2/6/2017 C-2016-2570929
PREHEARING MEMORANDUM - PENNDOT Prehearing Memorandum 2/1/2017 2/1/2017 C-2016-2570929
C-2016-2570929 PREHEARING CONFERENCE ORDER.PDF PreHearing Order 1/19/2017 C-2016-2570929
REPLY TO ANSWER - A EDWARD SCHWARTZ Reply to Answer 1/13/2017 1/18/2017 C-2016-2570929
C-2016-2570929 INITIAL CALL IN TELEPHONIC PREHEARING CONFERENCE.DOCX Hearing Notice 1/4/2017 C-2016-2570929
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF D GROMELSKI - LAPLUME TOWNSHIP Notice of Appearance 12/29/2016 12/29/2016 C-2016-2570929
REPLY TO NEW MATTER - A EDWARD SCHWARTZ Reply to Answer 12/16/2016 12/20/2016 C-2016-2570929
REPLY TO NEW MATTER - NORFOLK SOUTHERN RAILWAY Answer to Petition 12/9/2016 12/12/2016 C-2016-2570929
REPLY TO PENNDOT NEW MATTER - A EDWARD SCHWARTZ Reply to Answer 12/5/2016 12/8/2016 C-2016-2570929
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE-FREDERICKSON FOR LACKAWANNA CNTY Notice of Appearance 12/1/2016 12/1/2016 C-2016-2570929
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE - DUNLAP/NORFOLK SOUTHERN Notice of Appearance 11/21/2016 11/21/2016 C-2016-2570929
RESERVED FORMAL COMPLAINT NOTICE Secretarial Letter 10/31/2016 C-2016-2570929
SCHWARTZ V D&H RR FC NOTICE Secretarial Letter 10/12/2016 C-2016-2570929

 

Need More Help?

If you can't find what you're looking for here, please contact the PA Public Utility Commission. Call us at 1-800-692-7380 or contact us online.

Document Search

Public utility documents available electronically include case dockets, public meeting orders and more.

Document Search

Filing & Resources

Find utility-related reports, laws and regulations, federal filings, tariffs, procedures and more.

Filing & Resources

eFILING

Consumers, utilities and attorneys can save time by submitting documents to the PUC electronically.

Get Details

Customer Hotline 1-800-692-7380

© PUC All Rights Reserved