Skip to content

Docket Number C-2021-3024417

Case Summary
Docket Number C-2021-3024417 Status Closed
Applicant Utility Code 110300
Complainant FLORENCE PARKER CHAILLA Utility Name METROPOLITAN EDISON CO.
Respondent METROPOLITAN EDISON COMPANY AND CHOICE ENERGY LLC D/B/A 4 CHOICE ENERGY Utility Type Electric
Responsible Bureau LAW eFiling Confirmation Number 2043017
Date Filed 03/04/2021 Date Posted 03/04/2021
Case Description Florence Parker Chailla filed Formal Complaint vs. Metropolitan Edison Company and Choice Energy LLC d/b/a 4 Choice Energy.
Daily Actions
Action Date Description Date Posted
7/24/2023 Case Closed - No Active Tasks Exist for this Case - Case Closed as no Active Tasks exists for this Case 7/24/2023
10/31/2022 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Secretarial Letter - 3024417 LAW - Chailla Petition for Emergency Order' is eServed - {42D63773-1FAC-CF3F-A02D-842F16B00002} 10/31/2022
10/31/2022 Document Published on Web - Document 'Secretarial Letter - 3024417 LAW - Chailla Petition for Emergency Order' is made public 10/31/2022
10/31/2022 Document Served - Other - See Comments - EMERGENCY ORDER SERVED 10/31/22 10/31/2022
10/26/2022 Document Published on Web - Document 'Ntc of Appeal Denial Petition for Emergent Relief - Parker Chailla' is made public 10/26/2022
10/26/2022 Assigned Responsible Bureau - LAW 10/26/2022
10/26/2022 Document Attached to Case - Ntc of Appeal Denial Petition for Emergent Relief - Parker Chailla - Parker Chailla filed Notice of Appeal Denial Petition for Emergent Relief. 10/26/2022
9/15/2022 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Opinion and Order - 3024417-OSA - 9-15-22 PM - Exceptions to Initial Decision - Florence R Chailla v Met Ed and Choice Energy and MetEd' is eServed - {4758DDCF-C4E5-C33D-9813-8341A580000C} 9/15/2022
9/15/2022 Document Published on Web - Document 'Opinion and Order - 3024417-OSA - 9-15-22 PM - Exceptions to Initial Decision - Florence R Chailla v Met Ed and Choice Energy and MetEd' is made public 9/15/2022
9/15/2022 Document Served - Other - See Comments - Order Served by email and eservice 9/15/2022 9/15/2022
4/28/2022 Document Published on Web - Document 'Second Revisions to Exceptions - F Chailla' is made public 4/28/2022
4/28/2022 Document Attached to Case - Second Revisions to Exceptions - F Chailla - Florence Parker-Chailla filed second revisions to exceptions. 4/28/2022
11/30/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'Exceptions (REVISED) - Florence Parker Chailla' is made public 11/30/2021
11/30/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reply Exceptions - MET ED' is made public 11/30/2021
11/30/2021 Document Attached to Case - Exceptions (REVISED) - Florence Parker Chailla - Florence Parker Chailla filed (REVISED) Exceptions 11/30/2021
11/30/2021 Assigned Responsible Bureau - OSA 11/30/2021
11/30/2021 Document Attached to Case - Reply Exceptions - MET ED - Metropolitan Edison Company filed Reply Exceptions 11/30/2021
11/29/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reply Exceptions - Choice Energy LLC' is made public 11/29/2021
11/29/2021 Document Attached to Case - Reply Exceptions - Choice Energy LLC - Choice Energy LLC filed Reply Exceptions 11/29/2021
11/17/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'Ltr not filing Exceptions -Choice Energy LLC' is made public 11/17/2021
11/17/2021 Document Attached to Case - Ltr not filing Exceptions -Choice Energy LLC - Choice Energy LLC d/b/a 4 Choice Energy filed Letter stating that it will not be filing Exceptions to the Initial Decision 11/17/2021
11/16/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'No Exceptions Letter - Met Ed' is made public 11/16/2021
11/16/2021 Document Attached to Case - No Exceptions Letter - Met Ed - Met -Ed filed a Letter stating they will not be filing exceptions 11/16/2021
11/16/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'Exceptions - Florence Parker Chailla' is made public 11/16/2021
11/16/2021 Assigned Responsible Bureau - OSA 11/16/2021
11/16/2021 Document Attached to Case - Exceptions - Florence Parker Chailla - Florence Parker Chailla filed Exceptions 11/16/2021
10/28/2021 Document Served & Pend - Pend for Exceptions - EXCEPTIONS DUE 11/16/21 - REPLIES 11/29/21 10/28/2021
10/27/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'INITIAL DEC LTR - 20-10 C-2021-3024417.docx' is made public 10/27/2021
10/27/2021 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2021-3024417 Florence R Parker Chailla v Metropolitan Edison Company and 4 Choice Energy LLC ID.pdf' is eServed - {79A8D30B-E7F5-CA97-84A9-7CC1CD800000} 10/27/2021
10/27/2021 Document EServed to POR - Document 'INITIAL DEC LTR - 20-10 C-2021-3024417.docx' is eServed - {3D9F7B33-FD6D-C587-85FD-7CC1D4500000} 10/27/2021
10/27/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2021-3024417 Florence R Parker Chailla v Metropolitan Edison Company and 4 Choice Energy LLC ID.pdf' is made public 10/27/2021
10/27/2021 Document Served & Send to C&A - Other - See Comments - ID SERVED 10/27/21, EXCEPTIONS DUE 11/16/21, REPLIES DUE 11/29/21 10/27/2021
9/23/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'Chailla Exhibit 12.mp3' is made public 9/24/2021
9/23/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'Choice Exhibit 4.mp3' is made public 9/24/2021
9/8/2021 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Transcript Hrg 07-22-2021 (pgs 1-177)' Restricted on Web - {F46272FB-5BF7-C73A-8455-7BC16AB00000} 9/8/2021
9/8/2021 Document Attached to Case - Transcript Exhibits - Hrg 7/22/2021 - Transcript exhibits admitted at hearing held 7/22/2021 filed. 9/8/2021
9/8/2021 Document Attached to Case - Transcript Hrg 07-22-2021 (pgs 1-177) - Initial call in telephonic hearing before ALJ Coogan held Thursday, July 22, 2021 at 10:11 filed with exhibits 9/8/2021
6/24/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2021-3024417 Judge Change Notice.docx' is made public 6/24/2021
6/24/2021 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2021-3024417 Judge Change Notice.docx' is eServed - {80CC9247-2FF5-CDF4-86C1-7A3F34D00000} 6/24/2021
6/24/2021 Document Removed from Web - Document 'C-2021-3024417 Judge Change Notice.docx' has been removed from Web - {9BB204E9-D113-C733-8651-7A3A30D00000} 6/24/2021
6/23/2021 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2021-3024417 Prehearing Order.docx' is eServed - {A263DC3B-E420-C970-841D-7A3A65400000} 6/23/2021
6/23/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2021-3024417 Prehearing Order.docx' is made public 6/23/2021
6/23/2021 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2021-3024417 Judge Change Notice.docx' is eServed - {9BB204E9-D113-C733-8651-7A3A30D00000} 6/23/2021
6/23/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2021-3024417 Judge Change Notice.docx' is made public 6/23/2021
6/23/2021 Document Removed from Web - Document 'C-2021-3024417 Judge Change Notice.docx' has been removed from Web - {263ABF11-4469-C649-85CF-7A397BB00000} 6/23/2021
6/23/2021 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2021-3024417 Judge Change Notice.docx' is eServed - {263ABF11-4469-C649-85CF-7A397BB00000} 6/23/2021
6/23/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2021-3024417 Judge Change Notice.docx' is made public 6/23/2021
6/22/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Srvc resp Complainant discovery - MetEd' is made public 6/22/2021
6/22/2021 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Srvc resp Complainant discovery - MetEd - Metropolitan Edison Company filed Certificate of Service. 6/22/2021
6/17/2021 Document Attached to Case - Answer to New Matter - Florence Parker Chailli - Florence Parker Chailla filed a Reply to New Matter. 6/17/2021
6/17/2021 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer to New Matter - Florence Parker Chailli' Restricted on Web - {7CCF9E4C-E782-CF9C-857C-7A1688D00000} 6/17/2021
6/16/2021 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2021-3024417 Initial telephonic Hearing.docx' is eServed - {A149EE56-22C6-C9B1-8486-7A1627700000} 6/16/2021
6/16/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2021-3024417 Initial telephonic Hearing.docx' is made public 6/16/2021
6/14/2021 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2021-3024417 Setting Resolution Conference.docx' is eServed - {516543B8-E710-C673-8EB8-7A0B20800004} 6/14/2021
6/14/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2021-3024417 Setting Resolution Conference.docx' is made public 6/14/2021
6/11/2021 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2021-3024417 Order re Motions.docx' is eServed - {B127541A-E2CC-CD2D-84A8-79FB0FD00000} 6/11/2021
6/11/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2021-3024417 Order re Motions.docx' is made public 6/11/2021
6/2/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'Motion to Strike -Chailla' is made public 6/2/2021
6/2/2021 Document Attached to Case - Motion to Strike -Chailla - Florence Parker Chailla filed Motion to Strike Met-Ed’s Motion as Moot 6/2/2021
5/25/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer to Motion for Protective Order - Met -Ed' is made public 5/25/2021
5/25/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer to Motion for Summary Judgment - Met-Ed' is made public 5/25/2021
5/25/2021 Document Attached to Case - Answer to Motion for Protective Order - Met -Ed - Metropolitan Edison Company filed Answer to Motion for Protective Order 5/25/2021
5/25/2021 Document Attached to Case - Answer to Motion for Summary Judgment - Met-Ed - Metropolitan Edison Company filed Answer to Motion for Summary Judgment 5/25/2021
5/21/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'Rebuttal to Reply to Summary Judgment Motion - Chailla' is made public 5/21/2021
5/21/2021 Document Attached to Case - Rebuttal to Reply to Summary Judgment Motion - Chailla - Complainant filed Reply to Summary Judgment Motion. 5/21/2021
5/19/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment - Choice Energy' is made public 5/19/2021
5/19/2021 Document Attached to Case - Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment - Choice Energy - Choice Energy filed Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment 5/19/2021
5/17/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'Amended Motion Pro Hac Vice Coyle - Choice Energy' is made public 5/17/2021
5/17/2021 Document Attached to Case - Amended Motion Pro Hac Vice Coyle - Choice Energy - Choice Energy, LLC d/b/a 4 Choice Energy filed Amended Motion for Admission pro hac vice of John Coyle Esquire. 5/17/2021
5/7/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice (Coyle) - Choice Energy LLC' is made public 5/7/2021
5/7/2021 Document Attached to Case - Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice (Coyle) - Choice Energy LLC - Choice Energy LLC filed Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice of John Coyle, Equire. 5/7/2021
5/6/2021 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer to Formal Complaint - Choice Energy' Restricted on Web - {EA45E897-2E97-CAAE-88AF-793E34D00000} 5/6/2021
5/6/2021 Document Attached to Case - Answer to Formal Complaint - Choice Energy - Choice Energy LLC d/b/a 4 Choice Energy filed Answer to Formal Complaint 5/6/2021
5/4/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'Notice of Appearance -Deeney for Choice Energy' is made public 5/4/2021
5/4/2021 Document Attached to Case - Notice of Appearance -Deeney for Choice Energy - Notice of Appearance filed by Brian Deeney on Choice Energy LLC 5/4/2021
5/4/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'Letter to ALJ Re Motion for Protective Order - Met-Ed' is made public 5/4/2021
5/4/2021 Document Attached to Case - Letter to ALJ Re Motion for Protective Order - Met-Ed - Met-Ed filed letter to presiding ALJ regarding Motion for Protective Order. 5/4/2021
5/3/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'Motion for Summary Judgment - Chailla' is made public 5/3/2021
5/3/2021 Document Attached to Case - Motion for Summary Judgment - Chailla - Complainant filed Motion for Summary Judgment or in the Alternative for Unlawful Deceptive Billing Practices. 5/3/2021
4/30/2021 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2021-3024417 - Motion Judge Assignment.doc' is eServed - {EC629099-50F7-CAC7-8711-79233EB00000} 4/30/2021
4/30/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2021-3024417 - Motion Judge Assignment.doc' is made public 4/30/2021
4/6/2021 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer to Formal Complaint' Restricted on Web - {75D28CB0-25BA-4F34-A667-FA627ED16E32} 4/6/2021
4/6/2021 Document Attached to Case - Answer to Formal Complaint - Choice Energy filed Answer to complaint. 4/6/2021
3/29/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'Motion for Protective Order Etc - F Chailla' is made public 3/29/2021
3/29/2021 Document Attached to Case - Motion for Protective Order Etc - F Chailla - F Chailla filed Motion for Protective Order Etc 3/29/2021
3/24/2021 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer to Formal Complaint - Choice Energy LLC' Restricted on Web - {9ED2D66E-953F-CBE0-862A-786419D00005} 3/24/2021
3/24/2021 Document Attached to Case - Supporting Documentation-Exhibit.pdf - Choice Energy LLC filed answer to formal complaint. 3/24/2021
3/24/2021 Document Attached to Case - Communication-Answer to Formal Complaint.pdf - Choice Energy LLC filed answer to formal complaint. 3/24/2021
3/24/2021 Document Attached to Case - Answer to Formal Complaint - Choice Energy LLC - Choice Energy LLC filed answer to formal complaint. 3/24/2021
3/23/2021 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer/New Matter to Formal Complaint - Met-Ed' Restricted on Web - {E99D7E28-3E82-C215-878F-785F6BC00000} 3/23/2021
3/23/2021 Document Attached to Case - Answer/New Matter to Formal Complaint - Met-Ed - Metropolitan Edison Co filed Answer & New Matter to complaint. 3/23/2021
3/4/2021 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Formal Complaint - Parker Chailla' is eServed - {6EFC3D2F-2DB0-C5DD-B2B9-77FE7B400005} 3/4/2021
3/4/2021 Document Published on Web - Document 'Parker Chailla v MetEd and 4 Choice FC Notice' is made public 3/4/2021
3/4/2021 Document Served - Other - See Comments - Assigned to ALJ, copy to BIE Prosecution. 3/4/2021
3/4/2021 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Formal Complaint - Parker Chailla' Restricted on Web - {6EFC3D2F-2DB0-C5DD-B2B9-77FE7B400005} 3/4/2021
3/4/2021 Case Created - C-2021-3024417 3/4/2021
3/4/2021 Assigned Responsible Bureau - ALJ 3/4/2021
Public Documents
Document Name Document Type eFiling Confirmation Number Date Received Post On Date Date Served Reference Docket Number
SECRETARIAL LETTER - 3024417 LAW - CHAILLA PETITION FOR EMERGENCY ORDER Secretarial Letter 2043017 10/31/2022 10/31/2022 C-2021-3024417
NTC OF APPEAL DENIAL PETITION FOR EMERGENT RELIEF - PARKER CHAILLA Case Related Document 2043017 10/20/2022 10/26/2022 C-2021-3024417
OPINION AND ORDER - 3024417-OSA - 9-15-22 PM - EXCEPTIONS TO INITIAL DECISION - FLORENCE R CHAILLA V MET ED AND CHOICE ENERGY AND METED Order 2043017 9/15/2022 9/15/2022 C-2021-3024417
SECOND REVISIONS TO EXCEPTIONS - F CHAILLA Motion 2043017 4/26/2022 4/28/2022 C-2021-3024417
EXCEPTIONS (REVISED) - FLORENCE PARKER CHAILLA Exceptions 2043017 11/29/2021 11/30/2021 C-2021-3024417
REPLY EXCEPTIONS - MET ED Reply Exception 2043017 11/29/2021 11/30/2021 C-2021-3024417
REPLY EXCEPTIONS - CHOICE ENERGY LLC Reply Exception 2043017 11/24/2021 11/29/2021 C-2021-3024417
LTR NOT FILING EXCEPTIONS -CHOICE ENERGY LLC Letter 2043017 11/16/2021 11/17/2021 C-2021-3024417
NO EXCEPTIONS LETTER - MET ED Letter 2043017 11/16/2021 11/16/2021 C-2021-3024417
EXCEPTIONS - FLORENCE PARKER CHAILLA Exceptions 2043017 11/15/2021 11/16/2021 C-2021-3024417
INITIAL DEC LTR - 20-10 C-2021-3024417.DOCX Secretarial Letter 2043017 10/27/2021 10/27/2021 C-2021-3024417
C-2021-3024417 FLORENCE R PARKER CHAILLA V METROPOLITAN EDISON COMPANY AND 4 CHOICE ENERGY LLC ID.PDF Initial Decision 2043017 10/27/2021 10/27/2021 C-2021-3024417
CHOICE EXHIBIT 4.MP3 Transcript Exhibit 2043017 9/23/2021 C-2021-3024417
CHAILLA EXHIBIT 12.MP3 Transcript Exhibit 2043017 9/23/2021 C-2021-3024417
C-2021-3024417 JUDGE CHANGE NOTICE.DOCX PO Assignment Notice 2043017 6/24/2021 C-2021-3024417
C-2021-3024417 PREHEARING ORDER.DOCX PreHearing Order 2043017 6/23/2021 C-2021-3024417
CERT OF SRVC RESP COMPLAINANT DISCOVERY - METED Certificate of Service 2043017 6/21/2021 6/22/2021 C-2021-3024417
C-2021-3024417 INITIAL TELEPHONIC HEARING.DOCX Hearing Notice 2043017 6/16/2021 C-2021-3024417
C-2021-3024417 SETTING RESOLUTION CONFERENCE.DOCX Interim Order 2043017 6/14/2021 C-2021-3024417
C-2021-3024417 ORDER RE MOTIONS.DOCX Order 2043017 6/11/2021 C-2021-3024417
MOTION TO STRIKE -CHAILLA Motion 2043017 6/2/2021 6/2/2021 C-2021-3024417
ANSWER TO MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER - MET -ED Answer to Motion 2043017 5/24/2021 5/25/2021 C-2021-3024417
ANSWER TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT - MET-ED Answer to Motion 2043017 5/24/2021 5/25/2021 C-2021-3024417
REBUTTAL TO REPLY TO SUMMARY JUDGMENT MOTION - CHAILLA Answer to Motion 2043017 5/20/2021 5/21/2021 C-2021-3024417
OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT - CHOICE ENERGY Answer to Motion 2043017 5/19/2021 5/19/2021 C-2021-3024417
AMENDED MOTION PRO HAC VICE COYLE - CHOICE ENERGY Motion 2043017 5/17/2021 5/17/2021 C-2021-3024417
MOTION FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE (COYLE) - CHOICE ENERGY LLC Motion 2043017 5/6/2021 5/7/2021 C-2021-3024417
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE -DEENEY FOR CHOICE ENERGY Notice of Appearance 2043017 5/4/2021 5/4/2021 C-2021-3024417
LETTER TO ALJ RE MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER - MET-ED Letter 2043017 5/4/2021 5/4/2021 C-2021-3024417
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT - CHAILLA Motion 2043017 5/3/2021 5/3/2021 C-2021-3024417
C-2021-3024417 - MOTION JUDGE ASSIGNMENT.DOC PO Assignment Notice 2043017 4/30/2021 C-2021-3024417
MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER ETC - F CHAILLA Motion 2043017 3/29/2021 3/29/2021 C-2021-3024417
PARKER CHAILLA V METED AND 4 CHOICE FC NOTICE Secretarial Letter 2043017 3/4/2021 C-2021-3024417

 

Need More Help?

If you can't find what you're looking for here, please contact the PA Public Utility Commission. Call us at 1-800-692-7380 or contact us online.

Document Search

Public utility documents available electronically include case dockets, public meeting orders and more.

Document Search

Filing & Resources

Find utility-related reports, laws and regulations, federal filings, tariffs, procedures and more.

Filing & Resources

eFILING

Consumers, utilities and attorneys can save time by submitting documents to the PUC electronically.

Get Details

Customer Hotline 1-800-692-7380

© PUC All Rights Reserved