Skip to content

Docket Number F-2023-3037611

Case Summary
Docket Number F-2023-3037611 Status Closed
Applicant PECO ENERGY COMPANY AND DIRECT ENERGY SERVICES LLC Utility Code 125135
Complainant ROB NABORN AND CYNTHIA PRONKO Utility Name DIRECT ENERGY SERVICES LLC
Respondent PECO ENERGY COMPANY AND DIRECT ENERGY SERVICES LLC Utility Type Gas
Responsible Bureau OSA eFiling Confirmation Number
Date Filed 12/22/2022 Date Posted 01/12/2023
Case Description Rob Naborn filed Formal Complaint vs Direct Energy Services LLC.
Daily Actions
Action Date Description Date Posted
3/13/2024 Case Closed - No active tasks exist for this Case 3/13/2024
3/4/2024 Document EServed to POR - Document '3037611-OSA - Naborn & Pronko v PECO & Direct Energy (JFC) Statement - 2-22-24.pdf' is eServed 3/4/2024
3/4/2024 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Rewrite Opinion and Order - 3037611-OSA - 2-22-24 PM - Exceptions to Initial Decision - Robert Naborn and Cynthia Pronko v Direct Energy Services LLC and PECO Energy Co' is eServed 3/4/2024
3/4/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Rewrite Opinion and Order - 3037611-OSA - 2-22-24 PM - Exceptions to Initial Decision - Robert Naborn and Cynthia Pronko v Direct Energy Services LLC and PECO Energy Co' is made public 3/4/2024
3/4/2024 Document Served - Other - See Comments - Nature of Service : Certified Mail|Email|Eserve; REWRITE ORDER ENTERED 3/4/24 certified mail to POR Naborn 9489009000276548668005 3/4/2024
2/22/2024 Document Published on Web - Document '3037611-OSA - Naborn & Pronko v PECO & Direct Energy (JFC) Statement - 2-22-24.pdf' is made public 2/22/2024
2/22/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'VC Barrow Motion Naborn 3037611-OSA' is made public 2/22/2024
1/8/2024 Assigned Responsible Bureau - OSA 1/8/2024
9/26/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Exceptions - Direct Energy Svcs' is made public 9/26/2023
9/26/2023 Document Attached to Case - Exceptions - Direct Energy Svcs - Direct Energy Services LLC filed Exceptions. 9/26/2023
9/26/2023 Assigned Responsible Bureau - OSA 9/26/2023
9/15/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Fine Payment $500 - PECO' is made public 9/15/2023
9/15/2023 Document Attached to Case - Fine Payment $500 - PECO - PECO filed $500 fine payment. 9/15/2023
9/12/2023 Private Document Removed from Web - Private Document 'Transcript Hrg 4-17-2023 (pg 1-100)' has been removed from Web - {5BD93971-72BE-C212-8B19-87E66BD00000} 9/12/2023
9/12/2023 Document Removed from Web - Document 'Transcript Exhibits 04-17-2023' has been removed from Web - {8182560F-08FC-C110-8DB2-889C6F400000} 9/12/2023
9/6/2023 Document Served & Pend - Pend for Exceptions - EXCEPTIONS DUE 9/26/2023 REPLIES DUE 10/6/2023 9/6/2023
9/6/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'F-2023-3037611 Robert Naborn and Cynthia Pronk v Direct Energy Services LLC and PECO Energy Co ID.pdf' is eServed - {413AC818-D1F5-C2CF-859D-8A66CDE00000} 9/6/2023
9/6/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'INITIAL DEC LTR - 20-10 F-2023-3037611.pdf' is eServed - {84D20DF4-689F-CB88-873C-8A66DA700000} 9/6/2023
9/6/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'F-2023-3037611 Robert Naborn and Cynthia Pronk v Direct Energy Services LLC and PECO Energy Co ID.pdf' is made public 9/6/2023
9/6/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'INITIAL DEC LTR - 20-10 F-2023-3037611.pdf' is made public 9/6/2023
9/6/2023 Document Served & Send to C&A - Other - See Comments - ID SERVED 9/6/2023 EXCEPTIONS DUE 9/26/2023 REPLIES DUE 10/6/2023 Mailed certified to Rob Naborn 9171969009350294330538 9/6/2023
6/9/2023 Document Attached to Case - Transcript Exhibits 04-17-2023 - Transcript exhibits from hearing held on April 17, 2023 filed. 6/9/2023
6/9/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Transcript Exhibits 04-17-2023' is made public 6/9/2023
5/4/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Transcript Exhibits Hrg 4-17-2023' is made public 5/4/2023
5/4/2023 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Transcript Hrg 4-17-2023 (pg 1-100)' Restricted on Web - {5BD93971-72BE-C212-8B19-87E66BD00000} 5/4/2023
5/4/2023 Document Attached to Case - Transcript Hrg 4-17-2023 (pg 1-100) - Telephonic Hearing before ALJ Arlene Ashton held Monday, April 17, 2023 at 1:39 PM filed with exhibits. 5/4/2023
5/4/2023 Document Attached to Case - Transcript Exhibits Hrg 4-17-2023 - Transcript Exhibits admitted at Hearing held 4-17-2023 filed. 5/4/2023
4/14/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reply to Answer to FC - Naborn' is made public 4/16/2023
4/14/2023 Document Attached to Case - Reply to Answer to FC - Naborn - Cindy Pronko and Rob Naborn filed reply to answer to formal complaint. 4/16/2023
3/28/2023 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer to Amended Complaint - PECo' Restricted on Web - {1B3D4696-25FD-C4D0-8478-8729C0A00000} 3/28/2023
3/28/2023 Document Attached to Case - Answer to Amended Complaint - PECo - PECO Energy Company filed Answer to the amended complaint of Robert Naborn. 3/28/2023
3/24/2023 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Additional Info to Amended FC - Pronko/Naborn' Restricted on Web - {2D916868-61AD-C0DA-85D3-87102E900000} 3/24/2023
3/24/2023 Document Attached to Case - Additional Info to Amended FC - Pronko/Naborn - Cynthia Pronko and Rob Naborn filed additional information to amended formal complaint. 3/24/2023
3/22/2023 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Pronko Amendment to Formal Complaint' Restricted on Web - {0924EFCF-2A4C-CBDC-913F-8708FA400000} 3/22/2023
3/22/2023 Document Served - Other - See Comments - Assigned to ALJ, Copy to BIE. 3/22/2023
3/22/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Pronko Amendment to Formal Complaint' is eServed - {0924EFCF-2A4C-CBDC-913F-8708FA400000} 3/22/2023
3/22/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Pronko (Naborn) Amended FC Ltr.docx' is made public 3/22/2023
3/22/2023 Document Attached to Case - Pronko Amendment to Formal Complaint - Cynthia Pronko filed amended formal complaint. 3/22/2023
3/17/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'F-2023-3037611 Robert Naborn v Direct Energy Services LLC and PECO Energy Company IO on POs Order Corrected.docx' is eServed - {9547E042-3ED6-CCDB-8759-86F033500000} 3/18/2023
3/17/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'F-2023-3037611 Robert Naborn v Direct Energy Services LLC and PECO Energy Company IO on POs Order Corrected.docx' is made public 3/18/2023
3/17/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'F-2023-3037611 Hearing Cancellation and Rescheduling Notice' is eServed - {90631AE3-766A-C965-866C-86EF9A300000} 3/18/2023
3/17/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'F-2023-3037611 Hearing Cancellation and Rescheduling Notice' is made public 3/18/2023
3/16/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'F-2023-3037611 Robert Naborn v Direct Energy Services and PECO Prehearing Order.docx' is eServed - {541036E6-5512-CBD1-848A-86C747100000} 3/16/2023
3/14/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'F-2023-3037611 Cancelled - Rescheduled Initial Telephonic Hearing Notice' is made public 3/14/2023
3/14/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'F-2023-3037611 Cancelled - Rescheduled Initial Telephonic Hearing Notice' is eServed - {FB392B18-653D-C2A8-8681-86E10CF00000} 3/14/2023
3/9/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'F-2023-3037611 Robert Naborn v Direct Energy Services and PECO Prehearing Order.docx' is made public 3/9/2023
3/9/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'F-2023-3037611 Robert Naborn v Direct Energy Services and PECO Prehearing Order.docx' is eServed - {541036E6-5512-CBD1-848A-86C747100000} 3/9/2023
3/1/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'F-2023-3037611 Initial Call-In Telephonic Hearing Notice' is eServed - {532FD412-200F-CEE7-85A0-869E7D400000} 3/1/2023
3/1/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'F-2023-3037611 Initial Call-In Telephonic Hearing Notice' is made public 3/1/2023
2/22/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reply to Answer - Robert Naborn' is made public 2/22/2023
2/22/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer to Preliminary Objection - Robert Naborn' is made public 2/22/2023
2/22/2023 Document Attached to Case - Reply to Answer - Robert Naborn - Robert Naborn filed Reply to PECO Energy Company's Answer to Formal Complaint. 2/22/2023
2/22/2023 Document Attached to Case - Answer to Preliminary Objection - Robert Naborn - Robert Naborn filed Answer to Preliminary Objection. 2/22/2023
2/6/2023 Document Attached to Case - Answer to Formal Complaint - PECO Energy - PECO Energy Company filed Answer to the formal complaint of Robert Naborn 2/6/2023
2/6/2023 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer to Formal Complaint - PECO Energy' Restricted on Web - {C339B3A6-9C8C-C4CD-8B7E-86284BF00000} 2/6/2023
2/1/2023 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer to Formal Complaint - Direct Energy Services' Restricted on Web - {ADC34391-DBC3-C34D-87D0-860EA3100000} 2/1/2023
2/1/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Preliminary Objection - Direct Energy Services' is made public 2/1/2023
2/1/2023 Document Attached to Case - Answer to Formal Complaint - Direct Energy Services - Direct Energy Services LLC filed Answer and New Matter to the Formal Complaint of Rob Naborn and Preliminary Objection. 2/1/2023
2/1/2023 Document Attached to Case - Preliminary Objection - Direct Energy Services - Direct Energy Services LLC filed Answer and New Matter to the Formal Complaint of Rob Naborn and Preliminary Objection. 2/1/2023
1/17/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Formal Complaint - Naborn' is eServed - {1FD164A5-971E-4697-BAE0-19C9239BFC2A} 1/17/2023
1/12/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Formal Complaint - Naborn' is eServed - {1FD164A5-971E-4697-BAE0-19C9239BFC2A} 1/12/2023
1/12/2023 Document Served - Other - See Comments - Assigned to ALJ. 1/12/2023
1/12/2023 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Appeal Form - Naborn' Restricted on Web - {223CA8E3-EF1A-4C46-ADB7-B6572F4829DC} 1/12/2023
1/12/2023 Assigned Responsible Bureau - ALJ 1/12/2023
1/12/2023 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Formal Complaint - Naborn' Restricted on Web - {1FD164A5-971E-4697-BAE0-19C9239BFC2A} 1/12/2023
1/12/2023 Case Created - F-2023-3037611 1/12/2023
Public Documents
Document Name Document Type eFiling Confirmation Number Date Received Post On Date Date Served Reference Docket Number
REWRITE OPINION AND ORDER - 3037611-OSA - 2-22-24 PM - EXCEPTIONS TO INITIAL DECISION - ROBERT NABORN AND CYNTHIA PRONKO V DIRECT ENERGY SERVICES LLC AND PECO ENERGY CO Order 3/4/2024 3/4/2024 F-2023-3037611
3037611-OSA - NABORN & PRONKO V PECO & DIRECT ENERGY (JFC) STATEMENT - 2-22-24.PDF Statement 2/22/2024 F-2023-3037611
VC BARROW MOTION NABORN 3037611-OSA Motion 2/22/2024 F-2023-3037611
EXCEPTIONS - DIRECT ENERGY SVCS Exceptions 9/26/2023 9/26/2023 F-2023-3037611
FINE PAYMENT $500 - PECO Fine Payment 9/13/2023 9/15/2023 F-2023-3037611
INITIAL DEC LTR - 20-10 F-2023-3037611.PDF Secretarial Letter 9/6/2023 9/6/2023 F-2023-3037611
F-2023-3037611 ROBERT NABORN AND CYNTHIA PRONK V DIRECT ENERGY SERVICES LLC AND PECO ENERGY CO ID.PDF Initial Decision 9/6/2023 9/6/2023 F-2023-3037611
TRANSCRIPT EXHIBITS HRG 4-17-2023 Exhibit 5/4/2023 5/4/2023 F-2023-3037611
REPLY TO ANSWER TO FC - NABORN Reply to Answer 4/12/2023 4/14/2023 F-2023-3037611
PRONKO (NABORN) AMENDED FC LTR.DOCX Secretarial Letter 3/22/2023 F-2023-3037611
F-2023-3037611 ROBERT NABORN V DIRECT ENERGY SERVICES LLC AND PECO ENERGY COMPANY IO ON POS ORDER CORRECTED.DOCX Interim Order 3/17/2023 F-2023-3037611
F-2023-3037611 HEARING CANCELLATION AND RESCHEDULING NOTICE Hearing Cancellation Notice 3/17/2023 F-2023-3037611
F-2023-3037611 CANCELLED - RESCHEDULED INITIAL TELEPHONIC HEARING NOTICE Hearing Cancellation Notice 3/14/2023 F-2023-3037611
F-2023-3037611 ROBERT NABORN V DIRECT ENERGY SERVICES AND PECO PREHEARING ORDER.DOCX PreHearing Order 3/9/2023 F-2023-3037611
F-2023-3037611 INITIAL CALL-IN TELEPHONIC HEARING NOTICE Hearing Notice 3/1/2023 F-2023-3037611
REPLY TO ANSWER - ROBERT NABORN Reply to Answer 2/14/2023 2/22/2023 F-2023-3037611
ANSWER TO PRELIMINARY OBJECTION - ROBERT NABORN Answer to Preliminary Objection 2/13/2023 2/22/2023 F-2023-3037611
PRELIMINARY OBJECTION - DIRECT ENERGY SERVICES Preliminary Objection 2/1/2023 2/1/2023 F-2023-3037611

 

Need More Help?

If you can't find what you're looking for here, please contact the PA Public Utility Commission. Call us at 1-800-692-7380 or contact us online.

Document Search

Public utility documents available electronically include case dockets, public meeting orders and more.

Document Search

Filing & Resources

Find utility-related reports, laws and regulations, federal filings, tariffs, procedures and more.

Filing & Resources

eFILING

Consumers, utilities and attorneys can save time by submitting documents to the PUC electronically.

Get Details

Customer Hotline 1-800-692-7380

© PUC All Rights Reserved