Skip to content

Docket Number C-2019-3011586

Case Summary
Docket Number C-2019-3011586 Status Closed
Applicant METROPOLITAN EDISON COMPANY Utility Code 110300
Complainant BRIAN HOEFT Utility Name METROPOLITAN EDISON CO.
Respondent METROPOLITAN EDISON COMPANY Utility Type Electric
Responsible Bureau OSA eFiling Confirmation Number
Date Filed 07/15/2019 Date Posted 07/17/2019
Case Description Brian Hoeft filed Formal Complaint vs Metropolitan Edison Co
Daily Actions
Action Date Description Date Posted
11/21/2025 Case Closed - No active tasks exist for this Case 11/21/2025
11/20/2025 Document Published on Web - Document 'Opinion and Order - 3011586-OSA - 11-20-25 PM - Exceptions to Initial Decision - Brian Hoeft v Met-Ed' is made public 11/20/2025
11/20/2025 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Opinion and Order - 3011586-OSA - 11-20-25 PM - Exceptions to Initial Decision - Brian Hoeft v Met-Ed' is eServed 11/20/2025
11/20/2025 Document Served - Other - See Comments - Nature of Service : Certified Mail|Email|Eserve; ORDER ENTERED 11/20/25 email and certified mail to POR Meehan 9489009000276747865304 11/20/2025
10/15/2025 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reply Exceptions - FirstEnergy Pennsylvania Electric Co' is made public 10/15/2025
10/15/2025 Document Attached to Case - Reply Exceptions - FirstEnergy Pennsylvania Electric Co - FirstEnergy Pennsylvania Electric Co filed Reply Exceptions. 10/15/2025
10/6/2025 Document Published on Web - Document 'Exceptions - Brian A. Hoeft' is made public 10/6/2025
10/6/2025 Document Attached to Case - Exceptions - Brian A. Hoeft - Brian A. Hoeft filed Exceptions. 10/6/2025
10/1/2025 Document Published on Web - Document 'Exceptions - Brian A. Hoeft' is made public 10/1/2025
10/1/2025 Document Attached to Case - Exceptions - Brian A. Hoeft - Brian A. Hoeft filed Exceptions. 10/1/2025
10/1/2025 Assigned Responsible Bureau - OSA 10/1/2025
9/12/2025 Document Served & Pend - Pend for Exceptions - Nature of Service : N/A; Exceptions Due 10/1/2025 Replies Due 10/14/2025 9/12/2025
9/11/2025 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2019-3011586 ID SEC LETTER.pdf' is eServed 9/11/2025
9/11/2025 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Brian Hoeft v Metropolitan Edison Company ID.pdf' is eServed 9/11/2025
9/11/2025 Document Served & Send to C&A - Other - See Comments - Nature of Service : Certified Mail|Email|Eserve; INITIAL DECISION SECRETARIAL LETTER AND INITIAL DECISION SERVED 9/11/2025 Exceptions Due 10/1/2025 Replies Due 10/14/2025 9489009000276746801129 9/11/2025
9/11/2025 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2019-3011586 ID SEC LETTER.pdf' is made public 9/11/2025
9/11/2025 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Brian Hoeft v Metropolitan Edison Company ID.pdf' is made public 9/11/2025
4/23/2025 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Judge Change Notice' is made public 4/23/2025
4/23/2025 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Judge Change Notice' is eServed 4/23/2025
1/6/2025 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Transcript Hrg 12-19-2024 (pg 33-49)' Restricted on Web - {B46DD6A4-ADBA-CD21-87E7-943C66000000} 1/6/2025
1/6/2025 Document Attached to Case - Transcript Hrg 12-19-2024 (pg 33-49) - Initial Call-In Telephonic Evidentiary Hearing before ALJ Dennis Buckley held on Thursday, 12/19/2024 at 10:11 AM filed. 1/6/2025
12/19/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'COS AMENDED proposed exhibits - FE PA fka Met-Ed' is made public 12/19/2024
12/19/2024 Document Attached to Case - COS AMENDED proposed exhibits - FE PA fka Met-Ed - FE PA fka Med Ed filed Certificate of Service. 12/19/2024
11/12/2024 Document Attached to Case - Transcript PHC 03-19-2024 10:01AM Pgs 25-32 - Telephonic Prehearing Conference before ALJ Dennis J Buckley from hearing held on Tuesday, March 19, 2024 at 10:01AM filed. 11/12/2024
11/12/2024 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Transcript PHC 03-19-2024 10:01AM Pgs 25-32' Restricted on Web - {B895B3DC-4BDE-CA78-8843-9321BD100000} 11/12/2024
11/8/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Initial Call-In Evidentiary Hearing Notice' is made public 11/8/2024
11/8/2024 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Initial Call-In Evidentiary Hearing Notice' is eServed 11/8/2024
9/4/2024 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Hearing Cancellation Notice' is eServed 9/4/2024
9/4/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Hearing Cancellation Notice' is made public 9/4/2024
8/30/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Motion for Continuance - FE PA Met-Ed' is made public 8/30/2024
8/30/2024 Document Attached to Case - Motion for Continuance - FE PA Met-Ed - FE PA Met-Ed filed Motion for Continuance. 8/30/2024
7/11/2024 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Evidentiary Hearing Notice' is eServed 7/11/2024
7/11/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Evidentiary Hearing Notice' is made public 7/11/2024
5/16/2024 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Hearing Cancellation Notice' is eServed 5/16/2024
5/16/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Hearing Cancellation Notice' is made public 5/16/2024
5/16/2024 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2019-3011586 -Order Granting Continuance 5-16-2024.pdf' is eServed 5/16/2024
5/16/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2019-3011586 -Order Granting Continuance 5-16-2024.pdf' is made public 5/16/2024
5/7/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Motion for Continuance - FE PA Met Ed' is made public 5/7/2024
5/7/2024 Document Attached to Case - Motion for Continuance - FE PA Met Ed - FirstEnergy Pennsylvania Electric Co- Met Ed filed Motion for Continuance 5/7/2024
4/22/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Complainant’s Motion for Rehearing - Hoeft' is made public 4/22/2024
4/22/2024 Document Attached to Case - Complainant’s Motion for Rehearing - Hoeft - Complainant filed Motion for Rehearing 4/22/2024
4/9/2024 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Transcript PHC (Call In) 3-19-2024 (Pg 1-8)' Restricted on Web - {4E207BFE-8DBD-CD19-89C6-8EAF86900000} 4/9/2024
4/9/2024 Document Attached to Case - Transcript PHC (Call In) 3-19-2024 (Pg 1-8) - Prehearing Conference (Call In) before ALJ Dennis J. Buckley held March 19, 2024 at 10:01 a.m. 4/9/2024
3/21/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Evidentiary Hearing Notice' is made public 3/21/2024
3/21/2024 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Evidentiary Hearing Notice' is eServed 3/21/2024
3/21/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Prehearing Order - 3-21-24.docx' is made public 3/21/2024
3/21/2024 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Prehearing Order - 3-21-24.docx' is eServed 3/21/2024
3/20/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'Notice Appearance Meehan and Garcia and Withdrawal Lepkoski - FE PA fka Met Ed' is made public 3/20/2024
3/20/2024 Document Attached to Case - Notice Appearance Meehan and Garcia and Withdrawal Lepkoski - FE PA fka Met Ed - Notice of Appearance of James Meehan, Esq. and Daniel Garcia, Esq. on behalf of FE PA fka Met Ed and Withdrawal of Lauren Lepkoski. 3/20/2024
2/9/2024 Document Removed from Web - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Prehearing Cancellation and Rescheduling Notice' has been removed from Web - {60B15373-6361-C9EE-870E-8D8953500000} 2/9/2024
2/8/2024 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Prehearing Cancellation and Rescheduling Notice' is eServed 2/8/2024
2/8/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Prehearing Cancellation and Rescheduling Notice' is made public 2/8/2024
1/10/2024 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Prehearing Order 1-10-24.docx' is eServed 1/10/2024
1/10/2024 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Prehearing Order 1-10-24.docx' is made public 1/10/2024
12/15/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Telephonic Prehearing Conference Notice' is made public 12/15/2023
12/15/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Telephonic Prehearing Conference Notice' is eServed 12/15/2023
11/14/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'SMART METER NOTICE 3011586.pdf' is eServed 11/14/2023
11/14/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'SMART METER NOTICE 3011586.pdf' is made public 11/14/2023
11/14/2023 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Order - 2092655-LAW - 11-09-23 - Smart Meter Implementation - Lifting Stay Order - Revised - Final' is eServed 11/14/2023
11/14/2023 Document Published on Web - Document 'Order - 2092655-LAW - 11-09-23 - Smart Meter Implementation - Lifting Stay Order - Revised - Final' is made public 11/14/2023
11/6/2020 Document Attached to Case - Transcript - 10/22/2020 (pgs 8 - 24) - Further call in telephonic hearing w/ ALJ Buckley held Thursday, October 22, 2020 at 10:00 a.m. filed w/out exhibits. 11/6/2020
11/6/2020 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Transcript - 10/22/2020 (pgs 8 - 24)' Restricted on Web - {02AEB544-96EE-C6E6-885B-759A11B00000} 11/6/2020
11/4/2020 Document EServed to POR - Document 'STAY NOTICE with List of SMART METER PROCEEDINGS.docx' is eServed - {D46E02E2-86C5-CE8F-9017-759357E00000} 11/4/2020
11/4/2020 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Order - 2092655-LAW - 10-29-20 -Smart Meter Procurement and Installation' is eServed - {3621116B-8AE0-CE74-87FF-759355D00000} 11/4/2020
11/4/2020 Document Published on Web - Document 'STAY NOTICE with List of SMART METER PROCEEDINGS.docx' is made public 11/4/2020
11/4/2020 Document Published on Web - Document 'Order - 2092655-LAW - 10-29-20 -Smart Meter Procurement and Installation' is made public 11/4/2020
9/15/2020 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Further Telephonic Hearing Notice' is made public 9/15/2020
9/15/2020 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Further Telephonic Hearing Notice' is eServed - {31FDB0F3-338B-C4E6-8526-7491CE500000} 9/15/2020
8/18/2020 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Order 8-17-20.docx' is made public 8/18/2020
8/18/2020 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Order 8-17-20.docx' is eServed - {62116141-3C63-C7D6-844D-740175E00000} 8/18/2020
12/23/2019 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reply Briefs - Brian Hoeft' is made public 12/23/2019
12/23/2019 Document Attached to Case - Reply Briefs - Brian Hoeft - Brian Hoeft filed Reply Briefs. 12/23/2019
12/20/2019 Document Attached to Case - Reply Briefs - Met Ed - Metropolitan Edison Company filed Reply Briefs. 12/20/2019
12/20/2019 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reply Briefs - Met Ed' is made public 12/20/2019
11/18/2019 Document Published on Web - Document 'Main Brief - Met Ed' is made public 11/18/2019
11/18/2019 Document Attached to Case - Main Brief - Met Ed - Metropolitan Edison Company filed Main Brief. 11/18/2019
11/15/2019 Document Published on Web - Document 'Main Brief - Brian Hoeft' is made public 11/15/2019
11/15/2019 Document Attached to Case - Main Brief - Brian Hoeft - Brian Hoeft filed Main Brief. 11/15/2019
10/30/2019 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Electronic Transcript Init Prehrg Conf 9/30/19 (Pgs 1-7)' Restricted on Web - {0CFE1AF1-55AD-CCB7-87CE-6E1DA0B00000} 10/30/2019
10/30/2019 Document Attached to Case - Electronic Transcript Init Prehrg Conf 9/30/19 (Pgs 1-7) - Electronic Transcript pages 1 through 7 of Initial Prehearing Conference held September 30, 2019 in Harrisburg at 11:00 AM filed. 10/30/2019
9/10/2019 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reply to Answer - Brian Hoeft' is made public 9/10/2019
9/10/2019 Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer to Preliminary Objection - Hoeft' is made public 9/10/2019
9/10/2019 Document Attached to Case - Answer to Preliminary Objection - Hoeft - Brian Hoeft filed Answer to Preliminary Objections 9/10/2019
9/10/2019 Document Attached to Case - Reply to Answer - Brian Hoeft - Brian Hoeft filed Reply to Metropolitan Edison's Answer. 9/10/2019
8/29/2019 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Prehearing Conference Notice.doc' is eServed - {505B29E5-9998-C372-855F-6CDDFA400000} 8/29/2019
8/29/2019 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Prehearing Conference Notice.doc' is made public 8/29/2019
8/28/2019 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Motion Judge Assignment.doc' is eServed - {1222BF89-9618-CC12-875F-6CD823E00000} 8/28/2019
8/28/2019 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2019-3011586 Motion Judge Assignment.doc' is made public 8/28/2019
8/22/2019 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reply to Answer-Brian Hoeft' is made public 8/22/2019
8/22/2019 Document Attached to Case - Reply to Answer-Brian Hoeft - Brian Hoeft filed Reply to Answer 8/22/2019
8/21/2019 Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer to Preliminary Objection - Hoeft' is made public 8/21/2019
8/21/2019 Document Attached to Case - Answer to Preliminary Objection - Hoeft - Brian Hoeft filed Answer to Preliminary Objections. 8/21/2019
8/6/2019 Document Published on Web - Document 'Preliminary Objection- Met- Ed' is made public 8/6/2019
8/6/2019 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer to Formal Complaint-Met-Ed' Restricted on Web - {22822B89-C603-C9E7-8533-6C66FAD00000} 8/6/2019
8/6/2019 Document Attached to Case - Preliminary Objection- Met- Ed - Met- Ed filed Answer to Formal Complaint and Preliminary Objection 8/6/2019
8/6/2019 Document Attached to Case - Answer to Formal Complaint-Met-Ed - Met- Ed filed Answer to Formal Complaint and Preliminary Objection 8/6/2019
7/17/2019 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Formal Complaint' is eServed - {CB4113BF-5F4F-4F46-BD9E-40FD10358D76} 7/17/2019
7/17/2019 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Formal Complaint' Restricted on Web - {CB4113BF-5F4F-4F46-BD9E-40FD10358D76} 7/17/2019
7/17/2019 Document Served - Other - See Comments - Assigned to ALJ, copy to BIE Prosecution Assignment 7/17/2019
7/17/2019 Case Created - C-2019-3011586 7/17/2019
7/17/2019 Assigned Responsible Bureau - ALJ 7/17/2019
Public Documents
Document Name Document Type eFiling Confirmation Number Date Received Post On Date Date Served Reference Docket Number
OPINION AND ORDER - 3011586-OSA - 11-20-25 PM - EXCEPTIONS TO INITIAL DECISION - BRIAN HOEFT V MET-ED Order 11/20/2025 11/20/2025 C-2019-3011586
REPLY EXCEPTIONS - FIRSTENERGY PENNSYLVANIA ELECTRIC CO Reply Exception 10/14/2025 10/15/2025 C-2019-3011586
EXCEPTIONS - BRIAN A. HOEFT Exceptions 10/3/2025 10/6/2025 C-2019-3011586
EXCEPTIONS - BRIAN A. HOEFT Exceptions 9/30/2025 10/1/2025 C-2019-3011586
C-2019-3011586 ID SEC LETTER.PDF Secretarial Letter 9/11/2025 9/11/2025 C-2019-3011586
C-2019-3011586 BRIAN HOEFT V METROPOLITAN EDISON COMPANY ID.PDF Initial Decision 9/11/2025 9/11/2025 C-2019-3011586
C-2019-3011586 JUDGE CHANGE NOTICE PO Assignment Notice 4/23/2025 C-2019-3011586
COS AMENDED PROPOSED EXHIBITS - FE PA FKA MET-ED Certificate of Service 12/18/2024 12/19/2024 C-2019-3011586
C-2019-3011586 INITIAL CALL-IN EVIDENTIARY HEARING NOTICE Hearing Notice 11/8/2024 C-2019-3011586
HEARING CANCELLATION NOTICE Hearing Cancellation Notice 9/4/2024 C-2019-3011586
MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE - FE PA MET-ED Motion 8/29/2024 8/30/2024 C-2019-3011586
C-2019-3011586 EVIDENTIARY HEARING NOTICE Hearing Notice 7/11/2024 C-2019-3011586
C-2019-3011586 HEARING CANCELLATION NOTICE Hearing Cancellation Notice 5/16/2024 C-2019-3011586
C-2019-3011586 -ORDER GRANTING CONTINUANCE 5-16-2024.PDF Order 5/16/2024 C-2019-3011586
MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE - FE PA MET ED Motion 5/6/2024 5/7/2024 C-2019-3011586
COMPLAINANT’S MOTION FOR REHEARING - HOEFT Motion 4/19/2024 4/22/2024 C-2019-3011586
C-2019-3011586 EVIDENTIARY HEARING NOTICE Hearing Notice 3/21/2024 C-2019-3011586
C-2019-3011586 PREHEARING ORDER - 3-21-24.DOCX PreHearing Order 3/21/2024 C-2019-3011586
NOTICE APPEARANCE MEEHAN AND GARCIA AND WITHDRAWAL LEPKOSKI - FE PA FKA MET ED Notice of Appearance 3/20/2024 3/20/2024 C-2019-3011586
C-2019-3011586 PREHEARING ORDER 1-10-24.DOCX PreHearing Order 1/10/2024 C-2019-3011586
C-2019-3011586 TELEPHONIC PREHEARING CONFERENCE NOTICE Hearing Notice 12/15/2023 C-2019-3011586
SMART METER NOTICE 3011586.PDF Case Related Document 11/14/2023 C-2019-3011586
ORDER - 2092655-LAW - 11-09-23 - SMART METER IMPLEMENTATION - LIFTING STAY ORDER - REVISED - FINAL Order 11/14/2023 11/14/2023 C-2019-3011586
STAY NOTICE WITH LIST OF SMART METER PROCEEDINGS.DOCX Secretarial Letter 11/4/2020 11/4/2020 C-2019-3011586
ORDER - 2092655-LAW - 10-29-20 -SMART METER PROCUREMENT AND INSTALLATION Order 11/4/2020 11/4/2020 C-2019-3011586
C-2019-3011586 FURTHER TELEPHONIC HEARING NOTICE Hearing Notice 9/15/2020 C-2019-3011586
C-2019-3011586 ORDER 8-17-20.DOCX Order 8/18/2020 C-2019-3011586
REPLY BRIEFS - BRIAN HOEFT Reply Briefs 12/20/2019 12/23/2019 C-2019-3011586
REPLY BRIEFS - MET ED Reply Briefs 12/20/2019 12/20/2019 C-2019-3011586
MAIN BRIEF - MET ED Briefs 11/15/2019 11/18/2019 C-2019-3011586
MAIN BRIEF - BRIAN HOEFT Briefs 11/15/2019 11/15/2019 C-2019-3011586
REPLY TO ANSWER - BRIAN HOEFT Reply to Answer 8/23/2019 9/10/2019 C-2019-3011586
ANSWER TO PRELIMINARY OBJECTION - HOEFT Answer to Preliminary Objection 8/23/2019 9/10/2019 C-2019-3011586
C-2019-3011586 PREHEARING CONFERENCE NOTICE.DOC Hearing Notice 8/29/2019 C-2019-3011586
C-2019-3011586 MOTION JUDGE ASSIGNMENT.DOC PO Assignment Notice 8/28/2019 C-2019-3011586
REPLY TO ANSWER-BRIAN HOEFT Reply to Answer 8/22/2019 8/22/2019 C-2019-3011586
ANSWER TO PRELIMINARY OBJECTION - HOEFT Answer to Preliminary Objection 8/21/2019 8/21/2019 C-2019-3011586
PRELIMINARY OBJECTION- MET- ED Preliminary Objection 8/6/2019 8/6/2019 C-2019-3011586

 

Need More Help?

If you can't find what you're looking for here, please contact the PA Public Utility Commission. Call us at 1-800-692-7380 or contact us online.

Document Search

Public utility documents available electronically include case dockets, public meeting orders and more.

Document Search

Filing & Resources

Find utility-related reports, laws and regulations, federal filings, tariffs, procedures and more.

Filing & Resources

eFILING

Consumers, utilities and attorneys can save time by submitting documents to the PUC electronically.

Get Details

Customer Hotline 1-800-692-7380

© PUC All Rights Reserved